FIRST THEY CAME FOR THE PORN STARS ...
As someone who spends a good deal of his time mercilessly throttling his gentials to pornographic images, be they still, moving or completely imaginary, I care a great deal about governmental interference in the industry that produces them. Sure, I care about freedom, too, but that's a secondary concern. That's not because I hate freedom, it's because everything comes in second to my mighty prick.
That doesn't make me a shallow person, does it?
Despite wasting the better part of a century attempting to prosecute pornography and a forty-five year string of Supreme Court decisions that make that virtually impossible, the Bush administration has rekindled the war on porn. Thankfully, they don't have much else on their plate. After all, it isn't like there's a war or two going on.
Over the last two years, President Bush and his craven peon of an Attorney General, buttressed by a Congress of intellectual cowards, have been gradually been squeezing the porn industry and by extension free speech itself. Very few people have commented on it or dared to stand up to those curs, despite the fact that one of the new laws directly impacts bloggers everywhere.
First came 18 USC 2257, the Federal Record Keeping and Labeling Requirements Act of 2005. Actually, 2257 isn't an act at all. It's a Department of Justice guideline for enforcing the Child Protection and Obscenity Enforcement Act of 1988. Under 2257, the producers of pornography required to keep records identifying their models or performers and listing the names, addresses and real names, etc, as of 2005.
Here is how the law reads before Alberto Gonzales decided that he was Congress;
The statute requires the producers of such matter to "ascertain, by examination of an identification document containing such information, the performer's name and date of birth,'' to "ascertain any name, other than the performer's present and correct name, ever used by the performer including maiden name, alias, nickname, stage, or professional name,'' and to record this information. 18 U.S.C. 2257(b). Violations of these record-keeping requirements are criminal offenses punishable by imprisonment for not more than five years for a first offense and not more than ten years for subsequent offenses. See 18 U.S.C. 2257(i). These provisions supplement the federal statutory provisions criminalizing the production and distribution of materials visually depicting minors engaged in sexually explicit conduct. See 18 U.S.C. 2251, 2252.
The record-keeping requirements apply to "[w]hoever produces'' the material in question. 18 U.S.C. 2257(a). The statute defines "produces'' as "to produce, manufacture, or publish any book, magazine, periodical, film, video tape, computer-generated image, digital image, or picture, or other similar matter and includes the duplication, reproduction, or reissuing of any such matter, but does not include mere distribution or any other activity which does not involve hiring, contracting for[,] managing, or otherwise arranging for the participation of the performers depicted.'' 18 U.S.C. 2257(h)(3). There was however a very important exemption in the 1988 act and the subsequent 1992 DOJ enforcement regulations. The record-keeping requirements apply to "[w]hoever produces'' the material in question. 18 U.S.C. 2257(a). The statute defines "produces'' as ``to produce, manufacture, or publish any book, magazine, periodical, film, video tape, computer-generated image, digital image, or picture, or other similar matter and includes the duplication, reproduction, or reissuing of any such matter, but does not include mere distribution or any other activity which does not involve hiring, contracting for[,] managing, or otherwise arranging for the participation of the performers depicted.'' 18 U.S.C. 2257(h)(3). (emphasis mine) Which, I suppose, is all well and good. Rather, it was until Little Alberto decided - all on his own - that he was going to include what are called "secondary producers" in the enforcement provisions of the guidelines.
Who qualifies as a "secondary producer," you ask? Well, in a manner of speaking, pretty much everybody who publishes certain kinds of nudie pictures. Let's put it this way, if you take pictures of your girlfriend playing with herself and post them online, you're a "primary producer" and are expected to keep records. If I find those pictures and think that your girlfriend's cute enough to repost those pictures, I'm a "secondary producer" and am also required to keep the same records.  The secondary producer provision is completely impractical and serves only to punish speech rather than bad acts. George W. Bush and Alberto Gonzales want to stop pictures of girls playing with their nipples on the Internet and they'll do whatever it takes to get that done. Keep in mind that they're not prosecuting obsenity or even pretending to. The government has been laughed out of court too many times over the years for that. Instead, they've gotten creative and decided to jail people for book keeping violations.
There are two reasons why I've been very careful about what pictures I post here. Firstly, I know that most of you mongloids read this from work and I have no desire to get anyone fired. Secondly, while I'm not a US citizen or resident, I have been known to cross the border from time to time and would much prefer not going to federal prison forever for my trouble because of a 2257 violation.
Actually, it could be worse than that. Because Blogger runs through Google's California servers - and because of the United States government's annoying habit of applying its laws extraterritorially - I could theoretically still be prosecuted in federal court without even leaving my house. This was of particular concern to me as roughly half of the US government was reading my blog in the 2005-2006 period.
And, oh yeah, the United States government has taken the position that it can "inspect" and sieze any such documentation without anything as cumbersome or inconvenient as a search warrant.
Several commenters commented that the provision permitting seizure of records is unconstitutionally broad, could lead to prior restraint, and does not define what specific materials may be seized. The Department declines to adopt this comment. The Department notes that the regulatory and inspection scheme outlined in the final rule is a constitutional exercise of government power and, therefore, the presence of a law enforcement officer on the premises of the entity being inspected is authorized. In such a case, evidence of a crime may be seized by a law enforcement officer under the plain-view exception to the Fourth Amendment warrant requirement, and the materials seized do not need to be specifically described in the regulation that authorized the inspection. Eh, the Fourth Amendment was always kind of a pain in the ass anyway, with its demands of reasonableness and probable cause. In case you were wondering, everything I've cited so far is just from the first three pages of the 2257 regulations. It really doesn't matter if you like pornography or not. Anyone who cares about the First or Fourth Amendments should be terrified of 2257 and the manner in which that fucking dolt Gonzales is applying it. Anyone who looks at the titles of these laws can immediately see how fundamentally dishonest they are. First you have the Child Protection and Obscenity Enforcement Act, now there's the Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act of 2006. Notice how they're doing this "for the children?" Child pornography is one of the truly evil things in the world. Actually, I wouldn't even describe it as pornography as much as the documentation of the rape of a child. Production, distribution or possession of it such carry the harshest punishments possible. I don't think that imposing the death penalty for the production of child pornography is out of line. The problem is that none of these acts of Congress or the 2257 administrative changes address child pornography. The government just wants you to think that they do.  So far as anyone knows, only one underage performer - Traci Lords - was employed by a mainstream production company. And no one has ever asserted that she was knowingly employed as minor. She provided her agents and producers with fake indentification and went to work. Traci Lords, as she willingly admits, was a sick little girl. Several people associated with Lords were prosecuted for years until the United States government admitted that the ID used was a passport issued under the name of Traci Lords by the Department of State. Since prosecuting George Schultz would have proven embarrasing, all of the criminal charges were eventually dropped. The Traci Lords scandal, ladies and gentlemen, was in 1986. It is estimated that the mainstream pornography industry generates about 13 billion dollars each and every year. In comparison, Hollywood makes about 8 billion. Does anyone really think that they're going to kill the Golden Goose by getting involved in child pornography? Really? Well, it gets better. In the name of "the children," the Department of Justice wants porn stars to be individulally registered with the government.Ron Jeremy, Jenna Jameson - get ready to stand and be counted. The Department of Justice wants to come up with an official list of every porn star in America - and slap stiff penalties on producers who don't cooperate.
The new rules, proposed under the Adam Walsh Child Safety and Protection Act, would require blue-movie makers to keep photos, stage names, professional names, maiden names, aliases, nicknames and ages on file for the inspection of the department's Child Exploitation and Obscenity Section.
"The identity of every performer is critical to determining and ensuring that no performer is a minor," according to the new proposal.  Is there anyone out there who believes that Jenna Jameson might still be a child? She sure as shit hasn't looked like one lately. She's four years younger than I am and looks ten years older. And Ron Jeremy is 54 years old. Furthermore, he looked 54 when he was in high school. There was a time not too very long ago that the government was required to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that an individual or company was producing child pornography. That of course requires things like probable cause, search warrants and other stuff that requires people like Alberto Gonzales to actually work for a living. Much easier then to turn the burden of proof on its head and require the producers that they're not producing child pornography. This despite the fact that most reasonable people know that they aren't. You can look at these new regulations in one of two ways; either the Department of Justice is demonstrating its extraordinary laziness, or it is trying to destroy a completely legal business - a business, by the way, which has had its legality upheld by the United States Supreme Court repeatedly. The adult film industry plans to challenge the new rule as a violation of the First Amendment, said Paul Cambria, a lawyer for Hustler and other adult film companies. He sees it as a way to harass legitimate stag-film producers. "If they can't get you for obscenity, they'll get you for violating record-keeping," he said. Such a violation would carry a five-year penalty.
Make no mistake about it, these regulations aren't targeting child pornographers. They happen to already be in violation of dozens of state and federal laws. Accordingly, they don't tend to incorporate and set up offices and warehouses. Child pornographers are guys who produce from their fucking rec-rooms and distribute from their desktop computers. And prosecute them, they have to get access to things like credit card records. Those famously require a search warrant.  Now let's look at compartive harm to see just how necessary all of these regulations are. In the past 21 years, precisely one underage performer has slipped through the cracks of a major producer. And that happened because the United States government itself gave her the tools to do so. One person in 21 years. Given the lifestyle surrounding that industry,that's a really impressive record. Let's compare this to every Americans favorite toy, guns. 30,000 Americans were killed by firearms in 2005. More children in the United States are killed by guns every year than have American soldiers in Iraq. However, if federal officers enter a home or business without a proper search warrant, that evidence is excluded and more often than not the charges are dismissed under the Mapp exclusionary rule. Even the most strident of gun-rights advocates (and I consider myself one of them) cannot deny that guns cause far greater harm than does pornography, even child pornography. The numbers are irrefutable. Yet I think we all know what kind of an outcry there would be if the United States government mandated - under threat of five years imprisonment - that gun manfacturers keep detailed records of each and every one of their employees and contractors, which would then be subject to warrantless review by the FBI. Let's further assume that they were demanded to submit their names to a federal registry. I can say with reasonable certainty that most Americans would go batshit fucking crazy. Like it or not, pornography is a perfectly legitimate business and that has been affirmed by over 40 years of Supreme Court rulings. People like Gonzales have attempted to get around their First Amendment rights for as long as anyone can remember. Now the government is destroying the Fourth Amendment to get them. Despite all the evidence seperating mainstream pornography for the exploitation of children, despite the fact that several other industries cause more demonstrable harm to children, and despite the guarantees of the United States Constitution. I know that any number of conservatives are going to hit the ceiling over this essay, but they should consider that precedent actually means something. What happens to the sex industry at the hands of a quasi-conservative Bush Administration today could just as easily happen to the gun, tobacco or alcohol industries at the hands of a liberal administration tomorrow. And when it does, the Bill of Rights ceases to mean anything at all. Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: The Devil in Miss Jones By: Mike Ness From: Cheating at SolitairePermalink Labels: I Fought The Law, The Girls of Porn, The Smart Boy Blues
|