|
|
Sunday, March 16, 2008
|
|
THE USA PATRIOT ACT & THE DECLINE AND FALL OF CLIENT NINE
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.
-The Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution Did you know that Eliot Spitzer's cock is a national security threat? According to the federal government, it may very well be a weapon of mass destruction, and I couldn't be more thrilled that the United States could find at least one. Maybe I was wrong about everything I've said about President Bush and the invasion of Iraq and the year-long search for WMD was nothing more than a test run for a truly important mission: fishing around in the pants of the governor of New York.
Even though most of us have spent the week thinking that Spitzer was little more than the Felix to Jim McGreevy's Oscar in a remake of the Odd Couple, he's something more. Governor Spitzer is the most prominent victim of the USA Patriot Act.
The Patriot Act gave the FBI new powers to snoop on suspected terrorists. In the fine print were provisions that gave the Treasury Department authority to demand more information from banks about their customers' financial transactions. Congress wanted to help the Feds identify terrorist money launderers. But Treasury went further. It issued stringent new regulations that required banks themselves to look for unusual transactions (such as odd patterns of cash withdrawals or wire transfers) and submit SARs—Suspicious Activity Reports—to the government. Facing potentially stiff penalties if they didn't comply, banks and other financial institutions installed sophisticated software to detect anomalies among millions of daily transactions. They began ranking the risk levels of their customers—on a scale of zero to 100—based on complex formulas that included the credit rating, assets and profession of the account holder.
Another element of the formulas: whether an account holder was a "politically exposed person." At first focused on potentially crooked foreign officials, the PEP lists expanded to include many U.S. politicians and public officials who were conceivably vulnerable to corruption. The new scrutiny resulted in an explosion of SARs, from 204,915 in 2001 to 1.23 million last year. The data, stored in an IRS computer in Detroit, are accessible by law-enforcement agencies nationwide. "Terrorism has virtually nothing to do with it," says Peter Djinis, a former top Treasury lawyer. "The vast majority of SARs filed today involve garden-variety forms of white-collar crime." Federal prosecutors around the country routinely scour the SARs for potential leads. Long story short, that's how we all came to know and love Client Nine.
You'll notice that crazy shit like warrants aren't mentioned in those paragraphs. You'll also notice that the povisions that brought down Spitzer weren't even voted on by Congress. They are all administrative measure implimented by the Treasury Department and the banking industry. The government has now been relieved of its duty to investigate crime and has outsourced it to the banks. And now the Fourth Amendment is essentially meaningless.
I've always been suspicious of the Patriot Act and so has every other conservative who hasn't been pussy-whipped by George W. Bush. No serious conservative would ever suggest that it should be easy for the government to relieve the citizenery of their property and liberty outside of the very stringent requirements of the Constitution. You would be a fine authoritarian for believing the contrary, but that is not a conservative principle. Conservatives are philosophically suspicious of unlimited government power. Or at least they used to be.
There have been very few terrorism prosecutions under the Patriot Act. But as the years pass, the scope of the law has grown like a cancer. It has been used in tax evasion cases against strip club owners and now has taken the place of the state government in dictating where and how you can buy Sudafed. There are very few rational people who will tell you that strip clubs and antihistimines are existential threats to the United States.
As a matter of fact, terrorism itself isn't an existential threat to the United States and never was. To say that al-Qaeda is going to overthrow the government, establish a caliphate and behead Britney Spears is adorable rhetoric, but it ignores the facts and diminishes America both as a world power and as an idea.
Osama bin Laden is a mass murderer and human garbage. He destroyed three thousand people who did nothing worse than go to work on a Tuesday morning. But he is not the threat that the Soviet Union was. The USSR could have killed three million people with less effort in the same period of time whenever they chose to do so. Pretending otherwise is the height of intellectual dishonesty.
But even at the height of the Cold War, the Congress insisted on the rule of law. The government couldn't wiretap at will and they couldn't coerce private entities such as banks to do their dirty work for them. Even when faced with a potential nuclear apocalypse and the endless, drunken harranging of Joseph McCarthy, the Fourth Amendment and the concept of probable cause were seen as sacred.
Until very recently, the preservation of the Constitution was seen as being at least of equal importance as the preservation of the country. Without the Constitution, the United States is little more than a large parcel of real estate with unpredictable weather and populated by heavily armed, rude people with a fetish for electing idiots.
Because the Patriot Act is a criminal statute, we should be able to see concrete results from it by now through criminal prosecutions. And those results just aren't there, at least in regard to the War on Terror. There have been few if any successful terrorism prosecutions as a result of the Patriot Act. To suggest that the lack of prosecutions indicates success is a fallacy. A suspension of habeus corpus would have accomplished that, too.
However, the law has - like most laws do - metastasized and appeared in areas beyond its originial stated purpose and scope. The Treasury Department included public officials in the financial implimentation in the hope that it would catch foreign politicians laundering money for terrorists. That has yet to happen, but it did catch Eliot Spitzer's penis in a meat grinder.
I'm not losing any sleep over what has happened to the soon-to-be former governor. The man is a vindictive prick and a prosecutorial monster who built an entire craeer out of professional misconduct. This is a man who used his office to leak his suspicion that Richard Grasso was fucking his secretary simply because he didn't like Grasso's contractual retirement package. Spitzer's most dangerous perversions involved his use of the law, not what he did with whores on his own time.
His abuse of power was of a sort that would have left Richard Nixon breathless. If nothing else, Nixon waited until he had ultimate power to misuse it. Spitzer abused the power he already had as a means of gaining more. That a scumbag like him was brought low by out of control law enforcement and the blunt instrument of a police state like the Patriot Act is an irony of the most delicious sort and I glory in his downfall.
But that doesn't change the fact that it shouldn't have happened. Bin Laden wasn't running the Emperors Club. I doubt that al-Qaeda is building methamphetimine labs in Alabama or running strip clubs in Atlanta. And even if they were, the pre-existing federal laws or, more ideally, laws at the state level would be equal to the task of dealing with it.
During what passed for a debate back in the fall of 2001, Americans were promised that the Patriot Act was a national security measure and its extraordinary power would not be brought to bear against pre-existing crimes. As the record now clearly demonstrates, that has not been the case. It has been used almost exclusively to prosecute non-national security transgressions.
Ironically, the Patriot Act has allowed the entire American government to become what Eliot Spitzer was, a vindictive tyrant who perverts the law beyond its original intent to their own ends. Just as ironically, the expansion of police powers and the establishment of a national security government might accomplish what the terrorists never could, the contraction of the rights of the people as enumerated in the Bill of Rights.
The Justice Department itself admits that the Patriot Act has been misused by the FBI at least 1,000 times.
The Act allowed for the politically-motivated firings of US Attorneys that Alberto Gonzales had so much trouble remembering even happened and Karl Rove won't testify about. It has been used to local governments to deal with the homeless in ways that are patently unconstitutional. It has allowed for ex post facto investigations in drug cases in violation of Article One of the Constitution. And if you've travelled to Las Vegas in the last six years, chances are that the United States government has peeked at your "credit records, employment records, and in some cases, health records." And guess what? Those records stay on FBI computers and the Patriot Act explicitly states that they may be "'shared with third-parties where appropriate' yet no where in the legislation does it define who these third parties are or what conditions would be deemed appropriate for the sharing of such records."
Even though the Justice Department admits that the Patriot Act has been "misused" 1,000 times, no one at the FBI has yet been prosecuted for abuse of process. Feel safe yet?
Of course, modern conservatives haven't been all that concerned about that. They're still screaming about Kelo v. City of New London, which most of the state legislatures have rectified by themselves. The odds are that you'll never have to surrender your home to make way for a mall, regardless of what John Paul Stevens thinks. But the Patriot Act has touched the lives of every American who gets a cold. Thanks to President Bush and the Republican Congress, you have to essentially register with your local pharmacy to buy the smallest amount of antihistimine.
Whether you agree or not, you can at least make a constitutional argument about the relevence of Kelo to the Fifth Amendments takings clause. However, you would be hard pressed to square the investigative power of the government to pry into your private dealings without a warrant with the Fourth Amendment.
There will probably never be a caliphate in, say, southern New Jersey, but given the measures taken to prevent one, there might as well be. When your pharmacies, local libraries and banks become government stooges, can you really consider yourselves free?
Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: Shapes of Things By: Jimmy Page and the Black Crowes From: Live at the Greek
PermalinkLabels: I Fought The Law, The Death of Democracy
|
|
|
| |