Photobucket Enjoy Every Sandwich



Sunday, April 27, 2008


BEN KINGSLEY SAVES THE DAY

Afghanistan suffers from all of the problems Iraq does, only more so. The same flawed, illogical and monsterously fucking stupid American policies that have turned Mesopotamia a waking nightmare were actually invented in Afghanistan.

Seven weeks after 9/11, the United States brought the fight back to al-Qaeda and their Taliban sponsors. And it was a striking success despite the notable lack of actual American forces in the field. It was a war fought almost entirely by proxy. It was directed by the CIA, but actually conducted by the Northern Alliance and rented local warlords.

After the fall of Kabul, a Loya jirga was convened and Ben Kingsley was named acting president. He was elected in his own right by the Afghan people in 2004. Kingsley had never run much of anything prior to his being named president, but he was exceptional in Gandhi and Sexy Beast, so he had the enthusiasic backing of President Bush, who is something of a film buff.

Then the United States went away. They said something about having something better to do. Or maybe it left a note. Who can remember?

Anyhow, Afghanistan was left with a government headed by an Academy Award winner, drug dealers, war criminals of varying dispicability and several thousand NATO troops. Oh, and all of the major figures in both the Taliban and al-Qaeda were still wandering about. But whar are you going to do? The Bush administration had other priorities several hundred miles to the southeast.

Amazingly, the Rumsfeld doctrine of underwhelming force turned out to be complete nonsense and things went badly rather quickly. It turns out that you can't build a government around opium traffickers and movie stars and expect things to go well.

The way I see things, NATO is militarily about where the Soviets were in Afghanistan circa 1985. We control the cities, but once you get out into the country, you start having problems. Other than Canada and the Dutch, most of the NATO force is too scared to even go where the insurgency is, which is a novel way of prosecuting an anti-insurgency campaign.

Ben Kingsley has decided to make the prosecution of that campaign more interesting still.

Hamid Karzai, the Afghan president, has called on British and American troops to stop arresting Taliban insurgents in Afghanistan, saying that their operations undermined his government's authority and were counter-productive.

(...)

Karzai is facing re-election next year and may be hoping to bolster flagging support with a populist stance. However, in recent months relations have deteriorated seriously, with Western officials openly doubting the ability of the Afghan president, who was heavily backed by the US and the UK in 2001 after the fall of the Taliban regime, to manage rampant corruption and combat drug trafficking in the war-wracked southwest Asian state.
I particularly love the part about combating drug trafficking. The United States sought the co-operation of local warlords who were known to be involved in the drug trade. Now the U.S wants Ben Kingsley to do something about it. I'm not sure how to break this to the American and British governments, but they have a monopoly on air power and can napalm the poppy fields anytime they choose. The president of Afghanistan, on the other hand, cannot leave the house with at least four assassination attempts occurring.

I'd love to be in one of those summits, where Bush leans over and says "Hey, those drug dealers that we paid off for three years, can you do something about them?"

Karzai said he wanted American forces to stop arresting suspected Taliban members and their supporters, saying that fear of arrest and their past mistreatment were discouraging them from coming forward to lay down their arms. 'It has to happen,' he said. 'We have to make sure that when a Talib comes to Afghanistan ... he is safe from arrest by the coalition.'

Efforts at winning over Taliban fighters or sympathisers are mired in confusion: Nato allies in Afghanistan are divided over the exact nature of the amnesty or 'reconciliation programme' for insurgents. British policy, despite official insistence that 'there are no negotiations with the Taliban', is to weaken the radical Islamic movement by splitting off foot soldiers tempted by money or misled by tribal chiefs, religious leaders and ideologues from a 'hardcore' of leaders.
It appears that Ben Kingsley's policy is in direct conflict with NATO's. And it would be, but for the fact that NATO doesn't appear to have a policy at all. Having one would be a good place to start. After all, we've been there for six and a half years.

Having said that, we're doing a good job of pretending that Afghanistan is a democracy. That being the case, we're sort of obligated to at least pretend to care what that country's elected president has to say, even though it is unmitigated nonsense. But nonsense or not, it is his country and he answers to the people, not NATO.

And that, teenagers, is where democracy and common sense conflict. It's also why I thought the Bush doctrine of spreading democracy is not just incredibly stupid, but dangerously counter to American long-term strategic interests.

Let's take France as just one example. As you know, France is a democracy, although it has taken them no few than five tries to get it right. France is also famously difficult in its relationships with practically everybody. This is because the more democratic a society is, the more nationalistic it tends to be.

There is no guarantee that a democratic Iraq won't eventually be as hostile to Israel as its Baathist predecessor was, and no one should assume that a democratic Afghanistan won't seek some accomodation with the Taliban.

And that's where democracy directly conflicts with American national security and that of its NATO allies. The Taliban and al-Qaeda declared war on the West on September 11, 2001. And recent Afghan history indicates that there cannot be co-existence with the Taliban. Eventually, they will return to power as they did in 1996. They will destroy those that would cooperate with them because their religious fervor demands no less.

Once that occurs, it presents a clear and present danger to the West. That is compounded by the return of civilian rule in Pakistan. With the fall of Pervez Musharraff in everything but name, there is no longer any realistic check on the military and, to a much more important degree, the Inter-Service Intelligence service. The ISI, more than anyone else, was instrumental in the creation and military training of the Taliban and assured their survival in power. And that occured under the civilian governments of Benazir Bhutto and Nawaz Sharif.

Because Musharraf, like Zia al-Huq before him, had unquestioned control of the Pakistani military and the ISI, it was generally assumed that they worked under his exclusive direction. And Zia and Musharraf knew that their policies had to be tempered with their desire to maintain healthy relations with the United States.

But the military and ISI have never respected civilian rule and have acted on their own under civilian government. It is a matter of historical fact that the ISI was training fighters who would later constitute the Taliban and al-Qaeda to wage jihad in Indian controlled Kashmir. Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif knew about that training, but lacked the power to stop it. And it very nearly led to the world's first nuclear exchange.

The ISI hated Bhutto, barely tolerated Sharif, and has no use at all for Ben Kingsley. Gandhi, as it happens, wasn't that well received in Pakistan. If history is any guide, the army and ISI will resume ignoring the Pakistani civilian authorities and resume their relationship with the Taliban. If that happens, all bets are off.

The United States and NATO can't leave Afghanistan anytime if the forseeable future, lest the Taliban return to power. We also can't override President Ben Kingsley on his domestic political decisions, lest we undermine him with his constituents and demonstrate how ineffective he actually is. We also can't topple him for two reasons; first, we have nothing to replace him with. Second, making a big show of creating an Afghan democracy and toppling it less than a decade afterward would look sort of bad.

So what do we do? Do we give Kingsley the berth he needs to fulfil his constitutional duty, even if that imperils our own security? Or do we recognize Afghan democracy for it is, fraudulent, ineffective and ripe for exploitation by the more unsavory elements of the Pakistani national security establishment?

These are the questions that President George W. Bush and his failed and ridiculous "democracy agenda" leaves us with as he rides off into the sunset to establish some retarded democracy institute and "replenish the old coffers."

Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: Roland the Headless Thompson Gunner By: Warren Zevon From: Excitable Boy

Permalink

Labels: ,

5:24 PM