Photobucket Enjoy Every Sandwich



Sunday, July 29, 2007


THE PERFECT AS THE ENEMY OF THE GOOD: UNDERSTANDING PAKISTAN AND THE WAR ON TERROR

"Every nation, in every region, now has a decision to make. Either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists." -President
George W. Bush
Address to a Joint Session of Congress, 20 September
2001

The administration of President Bush is of the opinion that Pakistan can be one of two things in the war with al-Qaeda; perfect allies or implacable enemies. As is increasingly true of this president's opinions of foreign policy, it is not only wrong, it is dangerously so.

Pakistan can either be an incredibly cautious ally of the United States, or they can be the most dangerous foe the U.S could face in the War on Terror. Those are the choices. There are no others, and there likely won't be for the foreseeable future. To suggest otherwise is to display an ignorance of Pakistani geography, history and history that makes the second option more likely than not.

In the last few weeks the administration has used the declassified portions of the latest National Intelligence Estimate, which stated that the leadership of the Taliban and al-Qaeda - including Osama bin Laden and Ayman al-Zawahiri - are secreted in the Waziristan region near Pakistan's Northwest Frontier Province;
We assess the group has protected or regenerated key elements of its Homeland attack capability, including: a safehaven in the Pakistan Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA), operational lieutenants, and its top leadership.
Subsequently, the United States has used this information to publicly pressure the government of President Pervez Musharraf to do more in that autonomous region of his country. As the American presidential primaries approach, one can reasonably expect that pressure to steadily increase, with potentially disastrous consequences not just for U.S foreign policy, but for the security of South Asia and the world.

It is telling that you are not hearing the kind of statements from the British government that have been coming out of Washington. During the era of British India, the region remained steadfastly outside of London's control. In fact, Waziri raiding parties into British administered areas were a constant problem for the colonial government. Since the 1947 establishment of Pakistan, the federal government has also had little influence in the region. It is almost impossible to assume that the United States will achieve what the British and the Pakistanis themselves could not.

The Waziristan / North-West Frontier region has much more in common with Afghanistan than it does with Pakistan. Both are highly antagonistic to central authority and have responded to foreign interference. In its history, Afghanistan has expelled the British, Russian and Soviet empires, and it seems increasingly likely that they will expel NATO within the next five years.

If the United States pressures the Pakistani government to root out the Taliban and al-Qaeda in the autonomous regions, it is entirely possible that the country will erupt into a civil war, the consequences of which cannot be known. Should the military or Inter-Service Intelligence agency (ISI) - several elements of which are known to be sympathetic to not only the fundamentalist Waziri tribal elders, but the Taliban itself - launch a counter-coup against Musharraf, Pakistan could possibly become the world's largest terror state. The potential of Pakistan being everything the West fears most about Iran is very real. And the possibilities don't end there.

Pakistan is also not just a nuclear power, it has also been in a near state of war with neighbouring India, itself a nuclear power, for 60 years. Should a fundamentalist government, backed by the military and ISI, assume power, it is not outside the realm of possibility that it could launch a state-sponsored jihad against Indian controlled interests in Kashmir.

Since both powers successfully tested nuclear weapons in 1998, India and Pakistan have come close to nuclear exchanges twice, most recently when ISI-controlled jihadis assaulted the Indian Parliament on 13 December 2001 - less than three months after 9/11. One can reasonably assume that if India even suspects a jihadi Pakistani government of preparing an assault on their portion of Kashmir, they will respond with a pre-emptive strike against Pakistan's nuclear assets. India would likely cite the Bush Doctrine of pre-emptive self defense in doing so. Should such a strike prove unsuccessful, Pakistan would respond by launching their remaining weapons into Northern India, thereby starting the world's first nuclear exchange, and one involving the world's largest democracy.

Such a scenario has many unknowables. Would China threaten to retaliate against India if its Pakistani ally were attacked? How would the Sikh Punjabi region of India respond if it became the ground zero of a Pakistani retaliation to an assault by an Indian central government that it is hostile to? How could the United States argue against an Indian invocation of a self-defence doctrine that the U.S itself first propagated?

There is one question that Washington and its cheerleaders have not yet been forced to answer; "If the force of NATO has not been able to destroy the Taliban in Afghanistan, why would anyone think that Pakistan could do so in Waziristan and North-West Frontier Province?"

Furthermore, if the Musharraf government cannot establish military legitimacy within Pakistan's own national borders, how long could one reasonably expect Musharraf survive? If Musharraf strikes his northern provinces and embarrasses the military and ISI, which are already sympathetic to the Waziris and Taliban, the military and ISI will almost certainly wrest power from Musharraf. If there is one constant in Pakistani history, it is that no leader who loses a war long survives. Does anyone think that Musharraf would be replaced by someone more closely aligned with the West?

It is being reported this morning that Musharraf is readying his forces for such a strike on Waziristan. It will not only be an assault that the British Empire could not successfully carry out, it will be a strike on the Pakistani Constitutional order and the country's sixty-year history. If it is successful, Musharraf will go down in history as one of the great warriors. If it is not, the United States will be pushing him into his grave, with Pakistan as it now understood following closely behind. Hopefully, the consequences of such a failure would end there.

Other commentators are rejoicing in the revelation of talks between Musharraf and former prime minister Benazir Bhutto this Friday past. Again, this displays a profound ignorance of Pakistani politics and history. Combined with the Waziristan offensive, it makes the subcontinent more, rather than less, dangerous.

Explaining some history becomes necessary before I go further.

Many people wonder how India and Pakistan can be so different. India, despite its multitude of competing ethnicities, has been a continuous democracy for 60 years. Conversely, Pakistan has undergone no fewer than eight military coups in that period.

This has much to do with the foundation around which each nation built their society following their independence from Great Britian. India was founded on the principle of political parties, specifically the Congress Party. If a given leader proved too corrupt or incompetent to further tolerate, he or she would be deposed through the internal processes of the party. While it is messier than most Western democracies, India has progressed just fine under this system. When the Congress Party as a whole proved too corrupt as an institution, the BJP was elected to a term of government.

Conversely, Pakistani society was built around the civil foundation of the military. The election of political parties became secondary to the question to whether the military would long support them. Should a domestic issue become too controversial, or the party in power prove too corrupt, the military would assume political power and rectify the situation for a time. This has happened no fewer than eight times in sixty years.

A good example of how Pakistan works would be the contested 2000 presidential election in the United States. Rather than referring the matter to the Supreme Court of the United States, the Joint Chiefs of Staff would assume political power for approximately five years to allow the passions to cool. After that period passed, there would be a gradual return to democracy at the provincial level, and then a new federal election would held.

Rather than being a functioning democracy, Pakistan is a country built for the specific purpose of military juntas. The West can protest this all they wish, but the fact remains that the Pakistani people do not. The existence of a military fail-safe comforts them.

During their reported face-to-face talks in Abu Dhabi on Friday, Mrs. Bhutto demanded two things of President Musharraf. First, that she be allowed to bypass Pakistan's Constitutional limit on being prime minister more than twice. Second, that Musharraf resign his position as Chief of Staff of the military should he remain president.

It should be noted that Bhutto has been twice removed from power because of the kleptocratic government she and her husband presided over. In 1999, she went into exile rather than face indictment for the crimes alleged against her.

What Bhutto seems to expect is for Musharraf to use his influence with the military and judiciary to remove that indictment and then relinquish that influence, presumably to her. Given that the military and courts have already twice expressed their contempt for Mrs. Bhutto, it is almost impossible to see how she could long survive without Musharraf's influence. Such a government could only be expected to last months and would likely result in the premature deaths of Bhutto and Musharraf.

The above, of course, raises the question of just who would take over from a failed Musharraf/ Bhutto deal.

I doubt that it'll be a Thomas Jefferson democrat. What that holds for the War on Terror remains to be seen, but it can't be anything good.

If you want to know where the War on Terror is going, I recommend that you ignore the news, ignore the bloggers, ignore me. Just read some South Asian history. You'll get everything you need to know from that.

And it will scare the hell out of you.

Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: Draw the Line By: Aerosmith From: Draw the Line

Permalink


Labels: ,

10:18 AM