|
|
Thursday, December 13, 2007
|
|
WHO IS ABU ZUBAYHAH?
A couple of days ago I wrote about the interview given to ABC News by former CIA officer John Kiriakou. Mr. Kiriankou was directly involved in the capture of al-Qaeda operative Abu Zubaydah and his subsequent interrogation. While Kiriankou is adamant in stating that he did not take part in Zubaydah's waterboarding, he does assert his knowlege that it indeed took place as has been previously reported.
It was the first time that a current or former official admitted that such treatment took place. Previously, the party line was not to discuss intelligence gathering measures.
In the comments of my first little essay, the good and great Joan suggested that Mr. Kiriakou might have had a political motive for renouncing waterboarding;
I am inclined to listen closely to an ex-CIA operative. But it does not follow that I should be inclined to believe he is politically pure in his confessions, whichever way he paints it. He is trained, after all, to play in the field of deception. That's always possible, I suppose. So, I read the transcript of Kiriankou's ABC intereview. Here's how he describe Abu Zubaydah;
BRIAN:So you felt that he was-- he was very current. He knew what was going on.
JOHN: Very current. On top of-- of the current threat information he-- he was so well tied into the al Qaeda leadership, and he was-- he was highly thought of in al Qaeda, and he was very, very good at logistics, that we knew that he knew everybody who was worth knowing in al Qaeda. He knew cell leaders. That view is in keeping with a certain president that we all know and love.
Following his 28 March 2002 capture by the CIA and Pakastani authorities, President Bush gave a speech wherein he described Zubaydah and his importance.
The other day we hauled in a guy named Abu Zubaydah. He's one of the top operatives plotting and planning death and destruction on the United States. He's not plotting and planning anymore. He's where he belongs. I was interested at this point. As I was writing the first post, I was finishing Lawrence Wright's The Looming Tower: Al-Qaeda and the Road to 9/11. That book is considered the definitive history of the jihadist movement, winning the Pulitzer Prize and everything.
The Looming Tower names some 15-year-old kid who saved bin Laden's life during the anti-Soviet jihad and devotes two entire pages to his story. This book is so detailed that you learn the names of bin Laden and Zawahiri's wives and kids. The book should have been called Everything You Need to Know About Murderous Jihadi Garbage But Were Afraid to Ask.
Oddly enough, one of al-Qaeda's "top operatives" and someone "so well tied-into the al-Qaeda leadership" as Abu Zubaydah wasn't mentioned in the book. Not once. And The Looming Tower was written several years after Zubaydah's capture. After I finished writing that night, I even checked the index. I'm very thorough and this makes me both deeply sexy and highly annoying.
My curiosity now peaked, I began reading The One Percent Doctrine: Deep Inside America's Pursuit of Its Enemies Since 9/11 by Ron Suskind. Suskind's book has a great deal indeed to say about Zubaydah.
Since Zubaydah was captured in his Faisalabad hideout, the CIA also captured his computer and all of its contents. Those were turned over to an FBI agent named Dan Coleman, who had been investigating al-Qaeda since 1994 and was one of the foremost experts on them within the United States government in the days and months after 9/11.
In going through the contents of Zubaydah's computer, Coleman found a diary that went back a decade. And the contents of that diary were shocking indeed.
Zubaydah was a logistics man, a fixer, mostly for a niggling array of personal items, like the guy you call who handles the company health plan, or benefits, or the people in human resources. There was almost nothing "operational" in his portfolio. That was handled by the management team. He wasn't one of them
As disappointing as what was in the diary, Coleman's trained eye noticed what wasn't. The CIA had long suspected that the ubiquitous Zubaydah was involved in the August, 1998, bombings of the U.S embassies in Africa. He looked for enteries in the summer of 1998 in Zubaydah's diary. Nothing ... nothing but nonsense. (pages 95-96) Zubaydah was further described as "a travel agent, the guy who booked your flights" and "He was expendable, you know, the greeter ... Joe Louis in the lobby of Caesar's Palace, shaking hands." (page 100)
Of course, George Tenent devotes considerable space in his memoir to arguing with this assessment of Abu Zubaydah. However, he too has motive to shade the truth. After all, as Director of Central Intelligence, he was the guy who personally authorized Zubaydah's torture. I'm speculating here, but Tenent might look like a putz if he admitted to the Iraq "slam dunk" quote and to ordering the waterboarding of the wrong guy. You can only expect a guy to make himself look so bad in his own goddamned book before it gets humiliating.
For that reason, I wouldn't count on Vice-President Cheney's memoir verifying the Suskind account. As it is, he's going to have spend three or four chapters talking about shooting Harry Whittington in the face.
Furthermore, the CIA recently announced that it has it made it their practice to make the videotapes of these enhanced interrogations disappear. One of those tapes starred none other than Zubaydah. That those tapes were of some interest to various trial court judges and that their destruction may constitute an obstruction of justice seems to have mattered not at all. Christ, even Harriet Miers told the CIA not to destroy them. But who listens to Miers? She was just the lawyer of the president of the United States at the time. It appears that the only time the Agency listened to the Office of White House Counsel was when Alberto Gonzalez told them that the Geneva Conventions were "quaint."
This might be the most compelling reason to stay away from techniques like waterboarding. It makes one do things that are even dumber, more criminal and more politically damaging than the original act. As Richard Nixon taught us, "it's the cover-up that gets you."
Ron Suskind might be wrong in suggesting that Abu Zubaydah was the nerd among the cool kids. But he might be right. Would you admit to effectively torturing somebody you didn't have to? What would you do to avoid something like that becoming public knowledge? And what opinion do you think that the public would have about your competence and honesty if it did.
I agree with Joan that somebody might be spinning waterboarding for political purposes. I just disagree with her on who that might be and why. After all, John Kiriakou's public statements on the utility of Abu Zubaydah line up with those of George W. Bush rather nicely, so I doubt that he's a closet Democrat hunting for this president's scalp.
On the other hand, I could be wrong. It's been known to happen from time to time. At the end of the day, I'm not all twisted steel and sex appeal. Just 93%. I checked. The point is that I'm as imperfect as everybody else. I just don't like to advertise it.
None of the above should be taken to mean that I think that Zubaydah is by any means innocent. I think that membership in or association with al-Qaeda alone should get you a bullet in the head. But the U.S government vowed that things like waterboarding would be used sparingly and only on the worst of the worst. And that might not have been the case.
In any case, this story reminds me of Friedrich Nietzsche's advice to whoever fights monsters.
Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: For Whom the Bell Tolls By: Metallica From: Ride the Lightning
PermalinkLabels: I See Monsters, The Death of Democracy, The Serious Side of skippy
|
|
|
Wednesday, December 12, 2007
|
|
FOR THE LOVE OF GOD: THE LONELY DEATH OF AQSA PARVEZ
Aqsa Parvez was a Canadian girl living in the Toronto suburb of Mississauga. She loved music, photography and her friends. Like most girls of her age, she wanted more than anything to fit in.
For that she was strangled to death by her father on Monday night. Her desire to assimilate to her family's adopted country cost her her life. Aqsa Parvez was sixteen years old.
After several months of conflict within her family over her resisitence to wear the traditional Muslim hijab - several months over the course of which she took refuge both at an abused teen's shelter and at a friend's home - Aqsa Parvez went home went home at her older brother's urging to get a change of clothes before going to school. It would be the very last time she entered her home.
Her body would be found by paramedics Monday evening after the father, Muhammad Parvez, called 911 and reported that he had just killed his daughter. The paramedics found a very slight pulse and she was rushed to hospital and put on life support, but she couldn't be saved. Aqsa Parvez was sixteen years old.
I'm sure that once Muhammad retains and instructs counsel, he will say that the death of his daughter was a crime of passion and that it was never his intent to kill her. I'm sure that he'll say that it was an accident. I hope an eventual jury of his peers sees through that lie.
Manual strangulation leading to death takes anywhere from three to five minutes. Both the airway and the cartoid artery are constricted with continual, merciless pressure. The crushing of the windpipe must be excrutiatingly painful, as must be the brain's starvation of oxygen. The victim's body will resist and thrash about in an effort to breathe.
Strangulation is the most intimate, most personal way to murder another human being. Being only inches from the victim's face, the perpetrator will see the capallaries in eyes explode. He'll hear the victim's final sounds and actually feel the victim's final breath on his skin. There's abosolutely nothing accidental about manual strangulation. There is no more deliberate a way to kill someone. Muhammad Parvez strangled his sixteen year old daughter Aqsa to death on Monday night.
From what we know, Aqsa Parvez was terrified of her family. Until she graduated from Aqsa's school, her older sister monitored her behavior at school and reported it to her parents. Her friends reported that she was beaten at home. While it isn't unusual for sixteen year old girls to run away from home, it is highly unusual in the South Asian community. No child wants to end up in a shelter.
That is how Aqsa died. We know that Aqsa was lured home by her older brother, Waqas, and that she was murdered by her father. But that doesn't address the all-important "why."
According to her friends, Aqsa increasingly refused to wear the hijab, a traditional headscarf that orthodox Islam demands that women wear to protect their modesty. One can speculate that she didn't want to wear it because she wanted to assimilate more completely into Canadian society. Maybe she just wanted not to be seen as different from her friends and classmates. Perhaps it was just as simple as the fact that Aqsa Parvez was sixteen years old.
The media and the blogosphere is desperate to make this about the evils of Islam. It isn't. If anything, the lonely death of Aqsa Parvez is about the perversion of religion. To one degree or another, all monotheist religions drive certain of their followers to murder and, in certain circumstances, religious authorities condone and celebrate this.
Well, not in Canada. Not anymore.
As little personal enthusiasm as I have for it, I'm highly tolerant of the free expression of religion. Your beliefs mean little, if anything at all to me. My esteem for you is based entirely on your social conduct. Believe whatever you want, but your rights end at the point of violence.
So tolerant of religious expression is Canada that it has long refused to step in when religious figures advocate violence, although that is a clear violation of the Criminal Code of Canada. You should not be permitted promote the beating of children or acts of war against other ethnic or religious groups and hide behind your right to free expression in this country any longer. Furthermore, it is well past time that the crminal and immigration law be brought to bear on this.
If an Imam issues a fatwa allowing for the beating of girls not wearing the hijab or advocates violence against Israel, Jews or their interests, they should be arrested. If they are not citizens or permanent residents, they should be deported. The same applies to the sick followers of the late Meir Kahane, who advocate the violent expulsion of Palestinians from the Occupied Territories, or racist Christian Identity leaders and the membership of Operation Rescue that have been involved with or been themselves advocates of violence. Canada should have punished Catholic clergy who promoted the terrorist Irish Republican Army, but didn't.
I have great respect and interest in other cultures, but some of their practices are unacceptable to Canadian society. You do not get to bring your ethnic warfare here and you do not get to brutalize your children for whatever your culture or religion dictates. Even the most multicultural of societies cannot be asked to tolerate what happened in Mississauga on Monday.
The government of Pakistan either cannot or will not control the forces that drive people like Muhammad Parvez, but the government of Canada has the power and right to punish them harshly. If the current Canadian government isn't equal to that task, there's an election expected at almost any time.
We should send a very powerful message to the rest of the world: There is no other country in the world more welcoming to other people and cultures, and that this is something that the Canadian people are rightly proud of. But no longer will religion or culture - any religion or culture - be a justification or shield for murder.
I can't think of a lonelier way to die than to be betrayed by your brother and murdered by your father in your very own bedroom, in the place and with the people you are supposed to be safest. And I can't think of anything more obscene than allowing it to be minimized as anything other than a vicious murder because of religion or culture.
For the love of God, Aqsa Parvez was sixteen years old.
Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll By: Bob Dylan From: The Times They Are A-Changin'
PermalinkLabels: The Interfaith Dental Clinic, The Serious Side of skippy
|
|
|
Tuesday, December 11, 2007
|
|
SHOULD THIS MAN GO TO PRISON? JOHN KIRIAKOU & THE MEANING OF TORTURE
Today, on the United Nations International Day in Support of Victims of Torture, the United States declares its strong solidarity with torture victims across the world. Torture anywhere is an affront to human dignity everywhere. We are committed to building a world where human rights are respected and protected by the rule of law.
Freedom from torture is an inalienable human right. The Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment, ratified by the United States and more than 130 other countries since 1984, forbids governments from deliberately inflicting severe physical or mental pain or suffering on those within their custody or control. Yet torture continues to be practiced around the world by rogue regimes whose cruel methods match their determination to crush the human spirit. Beating, burning, rape, and electric shock are some of the grisly tools such regimes use to terrorize their own citizens. These despicable crimes cannot be tolerated by a world committed to justice.
(...)
The United States is committed to the world-wide elimination of torture and we are leading this fight by example. I call on all governments to join with the United States and the community of law-abiding nations in prohibiting, investigating, and prosecuting all acts of torture and in undertaking to prevent other cruel and unusual punishment. I call on all nations to speak out against torture in all its forms and to make ending torture an essential part of their diplomacy. I further urge governments to join America and others in supporting torture victims' treatment centers, contributing to the UN Fund for the Victims of Torture, and supporting the efforts of non-governmental organizations to end torture and assist its victims.
No people, no matter where they reside, should have to live in fear of their own government. Nowhere should the midnight knock foreshadow a nightmare of state-commissioned crime. The suffering of torture victims must end, and the United States calls on all governments to assume this great mission.
-President George W. Bush June 26, 2003 I'm highly conflicted about the issue of torturing terrorism suspects. On one hand, I hope that those people are uncomfortable in the extreme. On the other, I don't like what it does to the United States of America, which as a general rule, is better than the people it goes to war with.
When people like Colin Powell and John McCain say that torture is unacceptable, I'm inclined to listen. McCain has a pretty intimate familiarity with torture, having suffered five and a half years of it in the Hanoi Hilton. I'd say that makes him a much better authority on the issue than President Bush or Vice-President Cheney.
Of course, the Bush Administration changed the definition of tortue in such a way that almost nothing qualifies. Under the new definition, on those activities that "result in major organ failure or death" can be considered torture.
That leads to some pretty important questions. Is it then acceptable to cut off the hands of a detainee? How about raping the wife or daughter of one before his eyes? Under the Bush definition, neither qualifies as torture. They are, however, means by which the Ba'athist government of Saddam Hussein conducted business. By all acounts, it was highly effective.
That raises an important question: does the United States want to be on the same moral plane as Saddam Hussein?
The argument for waterboarding and other "enhanced techniques" is that certain detainees have information that is so important that extraordinary measures are justified in getting it. Lives can and have been saved, you will be told.
If that is the case - and I have no doubt that it is - then why not remove a hand or assault the terrorist's family?
And therein lies my problem with enhanced interrogation techniques, the slippery slope that it puts us on. You can justify almost anything, but you quickly become exactly what you're fighting.
Under international law, terrorists are unlawful combatants and may be executed without trial upon their capture. I have no quarrel with that whatsover. If it were up to me, it would happen a lot more than it actually does. I couldn't be more supportive of assassination, which is also perfectly legal under both U.S and international law. Under Executive Orders 11905 and 12333 only political assassinations - meaning killing a head of state or government official - is prohibited. Not only is Osama bin Laden not a government official, he has been officially stateless since his Saudi citizenship was revoked in 1994. No one in al-Qaeda is covered under the 1976 and '81 executive orders.
That's fine. This is, after all, a war on terror. Combatants have been executed on the battlefield for as long as war has existed.
Before today, we had never heard from an American official who readily admits to having engaged in torture. John Kiriakou, a former CIA officer, spoke with ABC News about what he did.
In watching the video of the interview, which I encourage you all to do, you cannot help but like Mr. Kirakou. You also can't help but feel a great deal of distaste over what he did in the service of the CIA. He certainly seems to and states his opinion that the practice of waterboarding should be discontinued.
I'm inclined to agree. Despite whatever executive orders have been issued and whatever opinions the Department of Justice has issued, waterboarding and enhanced interogation techniques are of questionable legality under American law and are clearly unacceptable under international law. The FBI is specifically prohibited from participating in such interrogations for good reason.
Even if circumstances warrant something like waterboarding, that does not mean that the practice should be enshrined in American law. Firstly, it can't be, as the United States is a signatory to several treaties regarding torture and those treaties have the full force and effect of federal law. Since they were ratified by the senate, a president can't over-rule them with an executive order or an intelligence finding. Secondly, it isn't a practice that anyone would want to see become commonplace, which it almost certainly would if Congress allowed for it. Remember how the USA Patriot Act was only supposed to be used in the War on Terror? Well, now it's a tool in the drug war and even some tax evasion cases.
If a CIA officer engages in waterboarding or something like it, he or she should do so knowing that they are exposing themselves to possibile prosecution. If it turns out that there really was no other reasonable alternative, that officer may receive congressional immunity or a presidential pardon. But if an alternative to enhanced techniques exists, those techniques should be used instead of something like waterboarding.
It isn't waterboarding itself that I object to, it's where the practice can potentially lead. If simulated drowning is acceptable, why not electrocution? Why not burn the hands and feet of a captured terrorist? In controlled cases, neither of those would lead to organ failure or death.
But once retired CIA officers who have participated in waterboarding say that it shouldn't be used, we should listen.
Link ruthlessly stolen from Captain's Quarters
Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: Drown in My Own Tears By: Ray Charles From: The Birth of Soul
PermalinkLabels: I Fought The Law, The Serious Side of skippy
|
|
|
Saturday, November 24, 2007
|
|
DO THE RIGHT THING
On January 29, 1996, Christie Rose Christie was a 16-year-old girl at home babysitting her infant brother. No one but Omar Junior Johnson knew that that would be the last thing Christie would ever do.
On that date, Johnson forced his way into Christie's apartment in Toronto looking for money, jewlery and drugs. It was only as he left that he shot Christie with a sawed-off shotgun. Johnson and and his two friends had either gotten what they had come for or they didn't. In any event, there was no reason at all to kill that girl. But Johnson did kill her. That much is uncontested.
Christie would have been 28 today, but she'll be sixteen forever because of Johnson. Because of him, she never got to see her siblings grow up and she never got to have a family of her own. Junior Johnson took that away from her just as he took Christie away from her mother, Tracy.
Thankfully, Tracy was given the oppotunity to say goodbye to her daughter.
"She told me how much she loved me, what a good mom I was, she asked if her brother was alive, and she made me promise her that I would please just make sure they all stayed in jail and not hurt anyone else," Christie told reporters at a press conference on Wednesday.
"That was the last thing she got to say to me, so I just can't stop, I can't stop." Johnson was sentenced to life in prison with no chance of parole for ten years. In Canada, "life" is generally considered to be 25 years. Junior Johnson is now 29 years old and residing in the Kingston Penitentiary. One of his co-defendants, Feldon Bennett, was arrested just this week for a first-degree murder in Hamilton, Ontario. Bennett, who supplied the gun that took Christie's life was only sentenced to seven years for his part in her death.
That murdering son of a bitch has a parole hearing on December 4th. Christie's mother would very much like to prevent his release. So would I.
I'm disgusted that my country could even consider releasing a monster like this after serving fewer years than his victim was allowed to live. Remember, Christie Christie did nothing worse than stay home and babysit her brother and for that she lost her life. Twelve years isn't enough for a monster like Junior Johnson. He needs to stay in prison for as long as possible.
I remember Christie's murder as if it was yesterday. It horrified the entire city of Toronto and it should horrify you, too. Christie didn't have to die and there was no reason for Johnson to kill her.
I humbly ask all of you to do your part to bring some measure of justice for Christie and her mother, Tracy. I haven't asked my readers for much over the years. I'm asking you to help now.
Tracy Christie has a Facebook page. If you have one, add her as a friend and let her know that you're thinking of her during what must be a nightmare. Imagine how you would feel if your child's murderer was released just before Christmas. I learned last year what a really bad Christmas can be like and I'd like for you to reach out to Tracy.
Ms. Christie also supports Victims United for Change, which also has a Facebook account. Victims United is also planning a rally outside of Kingston during Johnson's parole hearing, to which they'll be providing transportation from Toronto. If you live in the GTA and an afford to take the day off - which I sadly can't - I encourage you to go. You can make arrangements by calling 647-238-7305.
Finally, you can contact the National Parole Board of Canada. If you wish to write them by snail mail, your letter should be directed to;
National Parole Board Ontario and Nunavut Region Cataraqui Corporate Centre 516 O'Connor Dr, Ste 100 Kingston, ON K7P 1N3
RE: Parole Hearing for Junior Johnson
You can reach the National Parole Board by telephone at 613-634-3857 and by fax at 613-634-3861. Your e-mails can be directed to info@npb-cnlc.gc.ca
I recognize that most of you aren't from Toronto, Ontario, or even Canada. But all of you have a voice and I'd like my government to hear it. If the National Parole Board of Canada hears from people around the world that the release of Omar Junior Johnson is unacceptable, they just might listen.
If you do nothing else as we approach Christmas, please bring the memory of Christie Rose Christie some justice and Tracy Christie some peace. Don't let that poor woman face the holidays knowing that the monster who killed her child is free. You really can make a difference. You can read more about Tracy Christie's campaign to keep her daughter's killer in prison here, here, here and here. I know this post is wildly different from the nonsense that I usually write about, but I feel strongly about this. I appreciate your indulgence. Thank you. Update: This is the letter that I sent to the National Parole Board moments ago; To Whom it May Concern, I write to you today in regards to the parole of Omar Junior Johnson, currently being held in Kingston Penitentiary. On January 29, 1996 the prisoner Johnson did in cold blood murder Christie Rose Christie in her own home. Miss Christie did nothing but stay home that day to babysit her infant brother. During the course of a home invasion, the prisoner Johnson shot Miss Christie in stomach with a sawed-off shotgun, causing her unimaginable suffering and ultimately leading to her death. The prisoner did this in a home in which an infant was present and after the underlying crimes - the home invasion and robbery - took place. No evidence has been entered into the record that the prisoner Johnson acted in self-defence, or in any way feared for his own safety. Having already committed his underlying crimes, the prisoner Johnson killed Miss Christie for no other reason than to disguise his involvement. To say that the prisoner's actions outraged the conscience of the city of Toronto understates the emotion that this case aroused. Please know that this emotion remains undeminished. It is my understanding that the prisoner continues to demonstrate no remorse for the actions he undertook on January 29, 1996. This serves only to aggrevate the pain of the Christie family. That should be a consideration of this honourable Board Furthermore, the prisoner, having been duly convicted by a jury of his peers for the murder of Miss Christie Rose Christie, should not be released as we enter the Christmas season. In the unlikely event that you find that the release of the prisoner Johnson serves the interest of justice, it would ill-serve the Christie family to know that the prisoner has been awarded his freedom during a season that their daughter and sister will never again enjoy. I personally implore you not to visit such pain upon the Christie family during this holiday season. During the prisoner's 2005 hearing, Ms. Tracy Christie was disallowed from wearing a shirt bearing her daughter's image. I respectfully ask that during the prisoner's hearing of December 4, 2006 this honourable Board look at Miss Christie's picture. I ask that this honourable Board look upon the occasion of the prisoner's hearing as serving the interest of justice for Miss Christie rather than the prisoner. The people of the city of Toronto are not yet willing or able to accept the release of the prisoner into our community, nor should we be asked to do so. The prisoner Johnson brutally murdered a teenage girl in the presence of her infant brother. The law-abiding people of Toronto are wholly unprepared to accept the prisoner, and the fact that he reportedly remains unrepentant for his crimes only cements that feeling. I respectfully petition this honourable Board to deny the prisoner's release until his next hearing. Respectfully, (My Real Name) Toronto, Ontario Update: If you like to make your feelings known to the National Parole Board, you can sign this petition. I did. Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: One By: U2 From: Achtung Baby Permalink Labels: The Serious Side of skippy
|
|
|
Friday, October 19, 2007
|
|
THE BUSH DOCTRINE IN THEORY & PRACTICE: KURDISTAN EDITION
We will starve terrorists of funding, turn them one against another, drive them from place to place, until there is no refuge or no rest. And we will pursue nations that provide aid or safe haven to terrorism. Every nation, in every region, now has a decision to make. Either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists. From this day forward, any nation that continues to harbor or support terrorism will be regarded by the United States as a hostile regime. -President George W. Bush, Address to a Joint Session of Congress, 20 September 2001 In the lead-up to his invasion of Iraq, President Bush opined forcefully and frequently that the United States was justified in toppling the government of Saddam Hussein because it was a state sponsor of terrorism and posed a direct threat to the America and its allies.
Surprisingly, the Bush Administration is less than enthusiastic about the parliament of Turkey having reached the same conclusion about neighboring Iraqi Kurdistan.
The Turkish parliament yesterday voted to allow military strikes against Kurdish separatists in northern Iraq, despite stiff U.S. opposition and appeals from Baghdad for time to purge the rebels.
A government motion seeking a one-year authorization for one or more incursions into Iraq was approved with the support of 507 lawmakers in the 550-seat house, with 19 voting against. The motion leaves it up to the government to determine the timing and scope of the operation and the number of troops to be sent.
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan has stressed that parliamentary approval would not mean immediate military action, signalling room for diplomacy.
Baghdad and Washington scrambled to dissuade Ankara from following through on military action.
Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki said he was determined to act against the separatist Kurdistan Workers' Party, which attacks Turkey from its bases in northern Iraq.
The PKK has waged a bloody campaign for Kurdish self-rule in southeast Turkey since 1984. The conflict has claimed more than 37,000 lives. Any fair-minded observer has to agree that, under this president's own doctrine of international relations, Turkey has a much stronger case for attacking Iraq than did the U.S in 2002-03.
In 2002, Washington argued that Iraq harbored terrorists and may have allowed the establishment of al-Qaeda training camps on its territory. That those camps were in the autonomous Kurdish zone and protected by U.N resolutions and American air power was wisely left unsaid.
Since the end of the first Gulf War nearly 17 years ago, the Kurdistan Worker's Party (or PKK) has escalated its terror attacks against Turkey and not infrequently engaged the militaries of both Turkey and Iran. Turkey responded with a low-level attempts at the ethnic cleansing of its southeastern frontier, which only served to invite more terorrism from the PKK.
Between the American wars in Iraq, the PKK fought rival factions in the autonomous zone. However, since the overthrow of Saddam, neither the Kurdish regional government, the Iraqi government in Baghdad, or the United States military - which has been charged with unrooting terror wherever it is found - has done much of anything about the PKK. To Turkish ears, the president's declaration that "you are either with us, or you are with the terorists" must ring hollow indeed.
Turkey has been a close American ally since the the end of the First World War and, as a member of NATO and under the Truman Doctrine, it enjoys an American security guarantee. There are currently 160,000 U.S forces in Iraq and the United States has done nothing to stop terror attacks against an ally by a group that the U.S itself has designated as a terrorist organization from a country it occupies. Indeed, Washington holds Iraqi Kurdistan up as an example for the rest of the region.
It then stands to reason that Ankara has every right to ask the United States with whom it stands, Turkey or the terrorists.
Of course, the fledgling government of Nouri al-Maliki would very much like to avoid a second foreign invasion of his country in less than five years and has pledged to Turkey's prime minister, Recep Tayyip Erdogan that such an exercise will be unnecessary.
Maliki told Erdogan on the telephone that Baghdad "is absolutely determined to end the activities and the presence" of the PKK in Iraq, the semi-official Anatolia news agency reported, quoting unnamed sources.
He asked for "a new opportunity" to resolve the issue through diplomatic means and proposed talks.
Erdogan welcomed the proposal but warned that Ankara cannot tolerate any "further waste of time." I think after 23 years, Turkey has been more than patient.
The obvious question is with what army will al-Maliki "end the activities and presence" of the PKK? The army under his control has yet to prove itself equal to the task of quelling the insurgency that has engulfed the territory under his direct command, and Maliki has little, if any, influence in Kurdistan. Indeed, one would be hard pressed to find anything as trivial as an Iraqi flag north of Kirkuk.
The United States currently has no forces at all in the north and even if it did, lacks the will or domestic political support to take on the PKK and face the possibility of a third major insurgency against its forces.
Therefore, there are few options other than Turkish unilateral action. Ironically, the White House is strssing diplomacy.
In Washington, President George W. Bush said the U.S. was "making it very clear to Turkey that we don't think it is in their interests" to send troops into Iraq. But Washington has lost leverage with Ankara because of a pending Congressional vote on a resolution branding the 1915-17 Ottoman massacres of Armenians as genocide.
Turkey strongly rejects the "genocide" tag and has threatened unspecified reprisals against its NATO ally. For George W. Bush to call for patience and diplomacy is certainly one of the more interesting phenomenons in recent history. That he decides what is and is not in the interest of other countries certainly is not. He is, when all is said and done, the decider.
Bush's evaluation of Turkish interests is certainly fascinating. Saddam Hussein presented no direct threat to the American homeland, all fantasies about "mushroom clouds in American cities" aside, and the terrorism he sponsored targeted few, if any, American citizens or interests. But terrorism was one of the two stated justifications for the March 19, 2003 invasion.
Yet "democratic" Iraq is currently providing both safe harbor and a base of operations to the PKK, which has attacked Turkish terroritory, interests and nationals repeatedly for years. Those were precisely the reasons the United States was justified in taking down the Taliban in Afghanistan.
It is important to remember that Turkey is not acting pre-emptively to some distant (and laughable) threat. It has been and continues to be attacked by a group that even the United States has declared a terrorist organization. And the Bush Administration is trying to slam the brakes down on that.
That begs an important question; "What is the War on Terror really about if not terror and going to war against it?" The United States was never attacked by Iraq, not even by proxy. One attack against the American homeland was launched from Afghanistan. Yet, this administration levelled two (albeit highly unpleasant) governments and engaged in a doomed exercise in nation building that it mocked just seven years ago.
Turkey, on the other hand, is in its third decade of attacks on its terrority by a group that everyone recognizes as terrorist. The Iranians know that the PKK is a terrorist group. But Turkey is supposed to wait around around for the United States and its puppet regime in Baghdad to do .... nothing. George W. Bush and Nouri al-Maliki have spent more time fighting Carl Levin than they have the Kurdistan Workers Party.
When one country invades another, it faces the risk of a native insurgency. That's the nature of war. The Turks have invaded no one. No, they find themselves invaded by a Kurdish foreign insurgency that believes it has found protection in the rhetoric of Washington. And for all intents and purposes, the PKK does have President Bush's protection.
It couldn't be more obvious that this president believes that his country alone has the right to respond to a threat - real and perceived - however and whenever it sees fit, yet reserves the right to restain other nations with clear and justified national security interests at stake. It is equally obvious that he is about learn a powerful lesson; that the world doesn't work that way.
Five years ago, President Bush was rather more liberal in using words like "terrorist" and "genocide" than he is today. He's now learning that those words have real long-term, and probably permanent, implications on America's relationship with Turkey.
The Kurds are the world's largest ethnic group without a nation of their own. Consisting of approximately 55 million souls, they are nearly twice the population of Canada. They have been oppressed, betrayed and slaughtered by every country in the region. Their tragic history, however, does not give them licence to engage in terrorism.
Ankara has the same right to self-defence that Washington does and they have a far more compelling case for conducting military operations in Iraq now than did the United States four and a half years ago. In fact, since America assumed responsibility fot Iraqi security by virtue of its occupation and disbanding of the Iraqi military, the Bush Administration has a special duty to prevent precisely what is happening now. It is now clear that it has been derilect in that duty.
That leaves it with nothing but bad options, and those options are getting worse by the day.
Mr. President, are you with the Turks or are you with the terrorists?
Editor's Note: I wrote this post in longhand at work yesterday. Of course, most of the arguments were also used in a far more humorous way by the Daily Show last night. I just can't win, can I?
Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: Welcome To The Terrordome By: Public Enemy From: Fear of a Black Planet
PermalinkLabels: ... And Then You're Gonna Die, Don't Know Much About History, The Serious Side of skippy, The Smart Boy Blues
|
|
|
Saturday, October 06, 2007
|
|
WORDS AND CONSEQUENCES
I supported the war in Iraq that removed Saddam Hussein from power. My reasons for doing so were completely different from those who waged that war and most of its other supporters.
I thought that the WMD argument that the Bush administration presented as a justification was nonsense, and I said so at the time. Using common sense, I assumed that there would only be a first use or transfer to terrorists of WMD by Iraq if the Ba'ath regime were mortally threatened. After all, one doesn't usually engage in an act of suicide unless one is already facing certain death.
Nor was I particularly persuaded by the atrocities that Saddam had committed - and continued to commit - against his own people. If one were to trouble themselves with listing the countries and regimes on earth by their brutality against their citizenry, Iraq would have a very difficult time breaking into the top five.
Domestic barbarism is not now a driving force behind American foreign policy and it never was. Germany's actions toward the Jews began long before the United States entered World War II and President Roosevelt never spoke publicly about them once it had. The United States did not intervene to stop the genocide in Rwanda and, unlike former President Clinton, I don't think it should have.
I supported the war for the simple reason that Saddam Hussein could not be trusted to keep the regional peace. He launched two unprovoked invasions of his neighbours; Iran in 1979, and Kuwait in 1990. Iraq was contained, for a time, by the United Nations Security Council, but the sanctions that were in place were easily evaded by Iraq and the support for them in the U.N was rapidly eroding.
If the sanctions fell apart, history indicates that Iraq would have gone on an arms-buying binge and attacked another of its neighbours sooner or later. As in 1991, that would have required American intervention. If the question was taking down the regime when it was weak, or waiting until it was strong, I preferred the former.
I also knew what the likely consequences would be in the summer of 2002. I was aware of the possibilty that the country could disintegrate into sectarian violence that could potentially envelop the region.
However, I thought that the Bush national security apparatus was experienced and wise enough to see these things as well, and would strive to prevent those outcomes as much as was possible. It is important to remember that while President Bush was a novice Texas governor, Dick Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld, Colin Powell, Condolezza Rice and Paul Wolfowitz had well over a century of foreign policy experience between them.
I supported them to conduct an operation that I wouldn't have trusted with, say, the Clinton administration. Needless to say, I was wrong.
The Bush administration relied more on idealism than on wisdom. There was almost no forward planning and the inserted force was woefully inadequate. The invasion was designed almost solely to prove or disprove a light force projection theory of Rumsfeld's.
The Coalition Provisional Authority was staffed by hacks and political contributors to the president's first election campign and the Republican National Committee. So ideological were they that Iraqis were given a flat tax before it could guarantee electricity or reliable water service. The decisions to disband the military and de-Ba'athify the civil service took a relatively small insurgency and made it massive, threatening and unstoppable.
Not only should President Bush's Iraq adventure be compared to Vietnam, it should be unfavorably compared. Vietnam was escalated in secret after President Johnson knew that the cause was lost. President Bush refused to escalate when it could have actually accomplished something in mid-2003 and has the temerity to question the sense of anyone who opposes his current, all-too-late escalation.
I believe all of the above to be grounds for impeachment. If federal judges who were confirmed by the Senate can be removed from office for drunkeness and insanity, a president can so be convicted for misdministration of office. If any of you operated your cars the way this president has conducted foreign policy, you would be convicted of criminal negligence and/or vehicular homicide.
The way that George Bush, Dick Cheney and Donald Rumsfeld invaded Iraq created a civil war. If American forces are withdrawn any time in the next five years, they could possibly create a holocaust. If that isn't an impeachable offense, I'm not sure what actually is.
In any event, for the United States to leave the Iraqis to persue a genocide they made possible would constitue a crime against humanity. All pretending to the contrary aside, the United States is the government of Iraq and will be for some time.
Christopher Hitchens supported the war for purely moral reasons. He was of a mind that Saddam was an evil fellow and long-overdue for removal. While not a wholehearted Bushie, Hitchens stayed on the Iraq bandwagon far longer than did most sensible people.
I disagree with Mr. Hitchens in some areas and agree with him heartily in others. However, he is a truly brilliant writer and rarely diappoints, regardless of your perspective. His articles and, in particular, his interviews, never fail to entertain and educate. As much as there can be a Mencken for our time now that Hunter Thompson is gone, Christopher Hitchens is it.
Unlike most bloggers, Hitchens has a much higher platform and a far greater voice. That voice has consequences that I'm sure that he never imagined.
In the upcoming issue of Vanity Fair, Mr. Hitchens comes face to face with that responsibilty. He learned that his writings directly influenced 23 year old Mark Jennings Daily, born on the Fourth of July, to enlist to fight in Iraq, where Lieutenant Daily was killed by an IED in Mosul on January 15, 2007.
I can't imagine what it would be like for something I've written to have such enormous human consequences, and I don't think Mr. Hitchens ever did either.
Hitchens did something that must have been agonizing for him, he contacted Lieutenant Daily's family, and participated in the interment of their son / brother / husband's ashes. In his account of the aftermath of Mark's death, we learn something far more important than the truism that the boys and girls who wear the uniform are heroes, more often than not, their families are, too. The soldiers are gone, but we should always keep in mind the families of the fallen.
I'm not going to blockquote the Hitchen's article at length, because you should read it for yourselves. But there is one part of it that the casual reader of my stupid blod should see. That's from the last letter Lieutenant Daily sent to his wife, Snejana.
One thing I have learned about myself since I've been out here is that everything I professed to you about what I want for the world and what I am willing to do to achieve it was true. … My desire to "save the world" is really just an extension of trying to make a world fit for you.
Can you imagine the depth of the love behind that sentiment? Think of what Lieutenant Daily could have achieved as a husband, as a father and a teacher.
That's what we lost this past January.
I hope that everyone who visits this stupid blog, clicks through and reads Christopher Hitchens' article. Better yet, I hope they buy the magazine itself.
And regardless of your feelings about the war, keep the memories of the fallen and your prayers for their families in your hearts.
Link Ruthlessly Stolen From The Ace of Spades HQ
Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: Soldier's Things By: Tom Waits From: Swordfishtrombones
PeramalinkLabels: The Serious Side of skippy, The Smart Boy Blues
|
|
|
Wednesday, August 29, 2007
|
|
TWO FACES OF INNOCENCE
On September 30, 1959, Steven Truscott was convicted of the first degree murder of 12-year-old Lynne Harper. The presiding judge at his trial sentenced Truscott to "be hanged by the neck until you are dead."
Steven Truscott was all of 14 years old. The Government of Canada, acting under the authority of Her Majesty the Queen, was perfectly prepared to hang a fourteen year old boy.
There was also the small matter of Truscott's innocence. Steven Truscott was not merely legally "not guilty," he was factually innocent. Innocent in thought, word and deed. Worse still, most Canadians have known this for longer than I've been alive. The only people in the country who argued otherwise was the federal government.
Even though it was later decided that executing a fourteen year old would be unnecessarily barbaric and his sentence commuted to life imprisonment, he was still branded a murderer. Despite his being paroled at the earliest opportunity in 1968 - in large part due to a belief in his actual innocence - Steven Truscott has had to live with the brand of being the killer of little Lynne Harper for 48 years. Even though he escaped the hangman's rope, Steven Truscott lost his life in 1958.
Yesterday morning the Ontario Court of Appeal gave it back. For the first time nearly half a century - almost forty years after most Canadians reached the same conclusion - Steven Murray Truscott is an innocent man in the eyes of the law.
Defiant to the end before the law, the people and basic common sense, the Crown was handed its final defeat in the matter of Regina v. Steven Murray Truscott.
In a decision released today, the court unanimously holds that the conviction of Mr. Truscott was a miscarriage of justice and must be quashed. The court further holds that the appropriate remedy in this case is to enter an acquittal. The court thus orders that Mr. Truscott should stand acquitted of the murder of Lynne Harper. The Court of Appeal wouldn't even give the Crown the minimum it sought, a new trial. Instead, Truscott was acquitted outright. A nightmare that begun twelve years before I was even born finally ended yesterday. Forty-eight years ago, Mr. Truscott's life was ruined by bad science, incompetent police, ambitious prosecutors who relied on the perjured testimony of at least one witness, and an excitable, misinformed public. Steven Truscott resurfaced a decade ago to begin the battle to win his life back. Yesterday he won.
The Truscott case is infamous in Canada, but virtually unknown everywhere else. Because of the change of the media's scope and reach, Richard Jewell's life was ruined instantly and in ways that were unimaginable during the orignial Truscott trial.
Mr. Jewell was working as a security guard at the 1996 Atlanta Olympics when he noticed a bag unattended where it wasn't supposed to be. He, acting by himself, cleared the area as best he could (which I can tell you from personal experience is no easy task) before a bomb exploded, killing one and injuring 111 others. Were it not for Richard Jewell's presence of mind and professionalism, there is very little doubt that there would have been a far greater number of fatalities.
Richard Jewell was a hero that night, and he was crucified for his trouble.
In the beginning, Jewell was celebrated world-wide as a hero. As I remember it, that last for all of a day, maybe two. Then a string of dimwitted and lazy FBI officials - extending directly into the office of the director, Louis Freeh - latched on to Mr. Jewell's professional ambitions (he wanted to be a police officer) and decided that he was the bomber.
Instead of doing anything crazy, like arrest him and charge him with the bombing, the FBI named Richard Jewell a "person of interest" and began leaking unfounded smears to the media, who reported them with glee. It was a truly horrid thing to watch and conditioned me to instinctively take the side of anyone named a "person of interest," because that phrase tells me that law enforcement and journalists are going to destroy that person for no reason at all.
I've never seen anything like what happened to Mr. Jewell. He was lionized one minute and demonized the next. It literally flipped in a day. Incompetence in the FBI and greed in the media was all it took to ruin a man's life. The fact that the FBI never had the evidence to lay charges and the media never bothered to ask why never seemed to enter into the case. Richard Jewell and his mother were prisoners in the own home - surrounded by unmarked FBI cars and network satellite trucks for over eighty-eight days.
Despite the fact that the bombing was later conclusively attributed to a right-wing psychopath named Eric Rudolph, who later went on to bomb a gay nightclub and an abortion clinc, it took the state of Georgia over ten years to thank Richard Jewell for what he did that night in Centennial Park - save an unknowable number of lives.
If nothing else, he got that. A craven, lazy and stupid law enforcement establishment, cheered on by the jackals at NBC and the Atlanta-Journal Constitution joyfully went about the task of destroying Richard Jewell for no reason at all. Everybody else - including myself - sat back and broke out the popcorn.
It took ten years, but Governor Sonny Perdue finally said thank you to Richard Jewell. 13 months later - yesterday - Richard Jewell died. He was 44 years old. No one in the media or the FBI ever really apologized to Mr. Jewell, but at least he died knowing that the people of Georgia appreciated him for what he did in the early morning hours of July 27, 1996.
Steven Truscott and Richard Jewell. Those names are but two reasons to never trust cops, courts or reporters to bring justice. Yes, both finally - in one case, a half-century late - received justice, but they recieved it in spite of the legal and media establishments, not because of them. The legal and media establishments were more than ready to throw both men into the abyss for no other reason than expediency.
When I think of Steven Truscott and Richard Jewell, I inevitably think about the death penalty. Truscott was sentenced to hang as a fourteen year old and it took almost fifty years to establish his innocence. I have no doubt whatsoever that Jewell would have been sentenced to lethal injection had things played out differently.
Because of language in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms that allows the Crown to appeal jury acquittals, I am unable to support the death penalty in Canada under any circumstances. With the maladjusted misfits in the Bush administration - people champoined by Alberto Gonzales and who have almost never been right about anything in the last six years - wanting to expedite executions, I feel my support for capital punishment in the United States waning as well.
I fail to see how anyone who fancies themselves a believer in small, limited government and federalism can possibly support that government's ability to execute citizen's more easily. I fail to see how the two can be logically reconciled. Taking the life of another under judicial edict is the most solemn duty a government can undertake. Increasingly, officeholders refuse to recognize that in the face of opinion polling.
Lately I've given a great deal of thought to Justice Harry Blackmun's lone dissent in Callins v. Collins.
From this day forward, I no longer shall tinker with the machinery of death. For more than 20 years I have endeavored--indeed, I have struggled--along with a majority of this Court, to develop procedural and substantive rules that would lend more than the mere appearance of fairness to the death penalty endeavor. Rather than continue to coddle the Court's delusion that the desired level of fairness has been achieved and the need for regulation eviscerated, I feel morally and intellectually obligated simply to concede that the death penalty experiment has failed. It is virtually self evident to me now that no combination of procedural rules or substantive regulations ever can save the death penalty from its inherent constitutional deficiencies. The basic question--does the system accurately and consistently determine which defendants "deserve" to die?--cannot be answered in the affirmative. It is not simply that this Court has allowed vague aggravating circumstances to be employed, see, e. g., Arave v. Creech, ___ U. S. ___ (1993), relevant mitigating evidence to be disregarded, see, e. g., Johnson v. Texas, ___ U. S. ___ (1993), and vital judicial review to be blocked, see, e. g., Coleman v. Thompson, 501 U. S. ___ (1991). The problem is that the inevitability of factual, legal, and moral error gives us a system that we know must wrongly kill some defendants, a system that fails to deliver the fair, consistent, and reliable sentences of death required by the Constitution. I'm not there yet. But I'm getting closer every year.
Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: Gallows Pole By: Led Zeppelin From: Led Zeppelin III
PermalinkLabels: I Fought The Law, Journalists Are Swine, The Serious Side of skippy
|
|
|
Sunday, July 29, 2007
|
|
THE PERFECT AS THE ENEMY OF THE GOOD: UNDERSTANDING PAKISTAN AND THE WAR ON TERROR
"Every nation, in every region, now has a decision to make. Either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists." -President George W. Bush Address to a Joint Session of Congress, 20 September 2001 The administration of President Bush is of the opinion that Pakistan can be one of two things in the war with al-Qaeda; perfect allies or implacable enemies. As is increasingly true of this president's opinions of foreign policy, it is not only wrong, it is dangerously so.
Pakistan can either be an incredibly cautious ally of the United States, or they can be the most dangerous foe the U.S could face in the War on Terror. Those are the choices. There are no others, and there likely won't be for the foreseeable future. To suggest otherwise is to display an ignorance of Pakistani geography, history and history that makes the second option more likely than not.
In the last few weeks the administration has used the declassified portions of the latest National Intelligence Estimate, which stated that the leadership of the Taliban and al-Qaeda - including Osama bin Laden and Ayman al-Zawahiri - are secreted in the Waziristan region near Pakistan's Northwest Frontier Province;
We assess the group has protected or regenerated key elements of its Homeland attack capability, including: a safehaven in the Pakistan Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA), operational lieutenants, and its top leadership. Subsequently, the United States has used this information to publicly pressure the government of President Pervez Musharraf to do more in that autonomous region of his country. As the American presidential primaries approach, one can reasonably expect that pressure to steadily increase, with potentially disastrous consequences not just for U.S foreign policy, but for the security of South Asia and the world.
It is telling that you are not hearing the kind of statements from the British government that have been coming out of Washington. During the era of British India, the region remained steadfastly outside of London's control. In fact, Waziri raiding parties into British administered areas were a constant problem for the colonial government. Since the 1947 establishment of Pakistan, the federal government has also had little influence in the region. It is almost impossible to assume that the United States will achieve what the British and the Pakistanis themselves could not.
The Waziristan / North-West Frontier region has much more in common with Afghanistan than it does with Pakistan. Both are highly antagonistic to central authority and have responded to foreign interference. In its history, Afghanistan has expelled the British, Russian and Soviet empires, and it seems increasingly likely that they will expel NATO within the next five years.
If the United States pressures the Pakistani government to root out the Taliban and al-Qaeda in the autonomous regions, it is entirely possible that the country will erupt into a civil war, the consequences of which cannot be known. Should the military or Inter-Service Intelligence agency (ISI) - several elements of which are known to be sympathetic to not only the fundamentalist Waziri tribal elders, but the Taliban itself - launch a counter-coup against Musharraf, Pakistan could possibly become the world's largest terror state. The potential of Pakistan being everything the West fears most about Iran is very real. And the possibilities don't end there.
Pakistan is also not just a nuclear power, it has also been in a near state of war with neighbouring India, itself a nuclear power, for 60 years. Should a fundamentalist government, backed by the military and ISI, assume power, it is not outside the realm of possibility that it could launch a state-sponsored jihad against Indian controlled interests in Kashmir.
Since both powers successfully tested nuclear weapons in 1998, India and Pakistan have come close to nuclear exchanges twice, most recently when ISI-controlled jihadis assaulted the Indian Parliament on 13 December 2001 - less than three months after 9/11. One can reasonably assume that if India even suspects a jihadi Pakistani government of preparing an assault on their portion of Kashmir, they will respond with a pre-emptive strike against Pakistan's nuclear assets. India would likely cite the Bush Doctrine of pre-emptive self defense in doing so. Should such a strike prove unsuccessful, Pakistan would respond by launching their remaining weapons into Northern India, thereby starting the world's first nuclear exchange, and one involving the world's largest democracy.
Such a scenario has many unknowables. Would China threaten to retaliate against India if its Pakistani ally were attacked? How would the Sikh Punjabi region of India respond if it became the ground zero of a Pakistani retaliation to an assault by an Indian central government that it is hostile to? How could the United States argue against an Indian invocation of a self-defence doctrine that the U.S itself first propagated?
There is one question that Washington and its cheerleaders have not yet been forced to answer; "If the force of NATO has not been able to destroy the Taliban in Afghanistan, why would anyone think that Pakistan could do so in Waziristan and North-West Frontier Province?"
Furthermore, if the Musharraf government cannot establish military legitimacy within Pakistan's own national borders, how long could one reasonably expect Musharraf survive? If Musharraf strikes his northern provinces and embarrasses the military and ISI, which are already sympathetic to the Waziris and Taliban, the military and ISI will almost certainly wrest power from Musharraf. If there is one constant in Pakistani history, it is that no leader who loses a war long survives. Does anyone think that Musharraf would be replaced by someone more closely aligned with the West?
It is being reported this morning that Musharraf is readying his forces for such a strike on Waziristan. It will not only be an assault that the British Empire could not successfully carry out, it will be a strike on the Pakistani Constitutional order and the country's sixty-year history. If it is successful, Musharraf will go down in history as one of the great warriors. If it is not, the United States will be pushing him into his grave, with Pakistan as it now understood following closely behind. Hopefully, the consequences of such a failure would end there.
Other commentators are rejoicing in the revelation of talks between Musharraf and former prime minister Benazir Bhutto this Friday past. Again, this displays a profound ignorance of Pakistani politics and history. Combined with the Waziristan offensive, it makes the subcontinent more, rather than less, dangerous.
Explaining some history becomes necessary before I go further.
Many people wonder how India and Pakistan can be so different. India, despite its multitude of competing ethnicities, has been a continuous democracy for 60 years. Conversely, Pakistan has undergone no fewer than eight military coups in that period.
This has much to do with the foundation around which each nation built their society following their independence from Great Britian. India was founded on the principle of political parties, specifically the Congress Party. If a given leader proved too corrupt or incompetent to further tolerate, he or she would be deposed through the internal processes of the party. While it is messier than most Western democracies, India has progressed just fine under this system. When the Congress Party as a whole proved too corrupt as an institution, the BJP was elected to a term of government.
Conversely, Pakistani society was built around the civil foundation of the military. The election of political parties became secondary to the question to whether the military would long support them. Should a domestic issue become too controversial, or the party in power prove too corrupt, the military would assume political power and rectify the situation for a time. This has happened no fewer than eight times in sixty years.
A good example of how Pakistan works would be the contested 2000 presidential election in the United States. Rather than referring the matter to the Supreme Court of the United States, the Joint Chiefs of Staff would assume political power for approximately five years to allow the passions to cool. After that period passed, there would be a gradual return to democracy at the provincial level, and then a new federal election would held.
Rather than being a functioning democracy, Pakistan is a country built for the specific purpose of military juntas. The West can protest this all they wish, but the fact remains that the Pakistani people do not. The existence of a military fail-safe comforts them.
During their reported face-to-face talks in Abu Dhabi on Friday, Mrs. Bhutto demanded two things of President Musharraf. First, that she be allowed to bypass Pakistan's Constitutional limit on being prime minister more than twice. Second, that Musharraf resign his position as Chief of Staff of the military should he remain president.
It should be noted that Bhutto has been twice removed from power because of the kleptocratic government she and her husband presided over. In 1999, she went into exile rather than face indictment for the crimes alleged against her.
What Bhutto seems to expect is for Musharraf to use his influence with the military and judiciary to remove that indictment and then relinquish that influence, presumably to her. Given that the military and courts have already twice expressed their contempt for Mrs. Bhutto, it is almost impossible to see how she could long survive without Musharraf's influence. Such a government could only be expected to last months and would likely result in the premature deaths of Bhutto and Musharraf.
The above, of course, raises the question of just who would take over from a failed Musharraf/ Bhutto deal.
I doubt that it'll be a Thomas Jefferson democrat. What that holds for the War on Terror remains to be seen, but it can't be anything good.
If you want to know where the War on Terror is going, I recommend that you ignore the news, ignore the bloggers, ignore me. Just read some South Asian history. You'll get everything you need to know from that.
And it will scare the hell out of you.
Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: Draw the Line By: Aerosmith From: Draw the Line
Permalink
Labels: The Serious Side of skippy, The Smart Boy Blues
|
|
|
Thursday, December 28, 2006
|
|
THOUGHTS ON THE SECRET FORD TAPES
I'm apparently much smarter than even I thought. In my eulogy for President Ford Wednesday morning, I wrote the following, "He wouldn't have invaded countries without first having realistic goals as to how to administer them and extricate American forces."
When I wrote that, I was assuming that Ford didn't support what was happening in Iraq or how the situation got to be that way. I learned last night that not only was Ford critical, he said as much over two years ago to The Washington Post's Bob Woodward.
Former president Gerald R. Ford said in an embargoed interview in July 2004 that the Iraq war was not justified. "I don't think I would have gone to war," he said a little more than a year after President Bush launched the invasion advocated and carried out by prominent veterans of Ford's own administration. In a four-hour conversation at his house in Beaver Creek, Colo., Ford "very strongly" disagreed with the current president's justifications for invading Iraq and said he would have pushed alternatives, such as sanctions, much more vigorously. In the tape-recorded interview, Ford was critical not only of Bush but also of Vice President Cheney -- Ford's White House chief of staff -- and then-Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld, who served as Ford's chief of staff and then his Pentagon chief. "Rumsfeld and Cheney and the president made a big mistake in justifying going into the war in Iraq. They put the emphasis on weapons of mass destruction," Ford said. "And now, I've never publicly said I thought they made a mistake, but I felt very strongly it was an error in how they should justify what they were going to do."
Unlike President Ford, I did think going to war with Saddam Hussein was necessary. In fact, I still do. But I never predicated the case for war on WMD. Yes, everyone thought that there was an active weapons program in Iraq, but that's not the sort of thing that you go to war over unless you are absolutely certain. It also opens you up to the argument from your political opponents - both foreign and domestic - that there is selective enforcement inherent in the policy. The North Korean and Iranian programs weren't a secret in 2002-03, the Bush administration didn’t talk much about them.
I believed that war was necessary because of Saddam’s proven capacity for strategic miscalculation. It’s as though Saddam couldn't get out of bed in the morning without initiating a military conflict that would quickly spiral out of control as evidenced by his aggression against both Iran and Kuwait.
Describing his own preferred policy toward Saddam Hussein's Iraq, Ford said he would not have gone to war, based on the publicly available information at the time, and would have worked harder to find an alternative. "I don't think, if I had been president, on the basis of the facts as I saw them publicly," he said, "I don't think I would have ordered the Iraq war. I would have maximized our effort through sanctions, through restrictions, whatever, to find another answer."
On this point, I believe that President Ford is mistaken. Saddam was growing more dangerous precisely because the sanctions regime was falling apart. Just as the French, Russians and Germans refused to support the war, they were also leading the charge to rescind the sanctions that kept Iraq boxed in. If his past behaviour is any indication, Saddam would have been emboldened by this, gone on an arms shopping spree, and done something monumentally stupid. Saddam was bound and determined to confront America, and doing so while he was weak was far better than ding so after he had an opportunity to rearm. The debate shouldn't have been over if there would be a war with Iraq, but when and under what circumstances. But I believe it is a mistake to think of the war as anything other than inevitable as long as Saddam was in power. That said, I agree with the former president that the administration's emphasis on Iraqi "freedom" was a disastrously naive notion and a major strategic miscalculation. "Well, I can understand the theory of wanting to free people," Ford said, referring to Bush's assertion that the United States has a "duty to free people." But the former president said he was skeptical "whether you can detach that from the obligation number one, of what's in our national interest." He added: "And I just don't think we should go hellfire damnation around the globe freeing people, unless it is directly related to our own national security." I thought at the time - and it seems abundantly clear now - that you cannot have freedom in an artificially created nation populated with people who have centuries of grievances against one another. You can have anarchy and civil war, to be sure, but not anything approaching democracy. At the very least, holding elections in the absence of total security was a recipe for disaster. Given that modern Iraq was created by wrong-headed Wilsonianism , it seemed to me that more Wilsonian thinking was hardly a plausible solution to the country's problems. And those were problems that were almost certain to get worse after Saddam had been toppled. After all, the destruction of Yugoslavia and the horrors of Bosnia didn't occur until after the yoke of communism had been lifted. Purple fingers aside, it couldn't be clearer that democracy, at least in the short term, has been a disaster in Iraq. There aren't any good options in Iraq and there never were. The country was held together by an authoritarian despot and once that despot was removed, the country crumbled. What President Bush didn't seem to understand - and still doesn't - is that a unified Iraq and democracy are mutually exclusive endeavours. One necessarily negates the other. Since the international community generally and Iraq's neighbours specifically would never have tolerated a partition of Iraq, that left the installation of an authoritarian regime. It was never the Baath Party or the Iraqi military that posed such a threat; it was the penchant for strategic miscalculation by Saddam Hussein and his sons. Either was capable of governing Iraq after Saddam and either would have kept the chaos that ensued after the war. Is that ideal? Certainly not, but neither is it entirely unique. More often than not, when the United States has intervened in foreign countries, they have left behind either an authoritarian civilian government or a military junta to govern. Prior to 2003, democracy was not the strategic objective of American foreign policy, international stability was. The Korean and Vietnam wars were not about freedom, they were about containing communism, and truly despotic regimes were tolerated in both countries to meet that end. Even today, the United States partners with some less than ideal partners in the War on Terror. It is now clear that President Ford understood these things. Ed Morrissey at Captains Quarters wrote about the Ford interviews this morning and suggested that the former president should have spoken out publicly, and that not doing so was almost cowardly. I admire Mr. Morrissey greatly and read him daily, but I disagree with him completely on this point. It may well be that President Ford made President Bush aware of his concerns privately. Although there's no indication that the incumbent seeks out the opinions of his predecessors, we'll never know for certain. But if Ford were to publicly criticize a sitting president's war policies, he would have done what so many conservatives justifiably scold Jimmy Carter for. As a former president, no one knew better than Gerald Ford that a president is elected to govern and for former presidents to object in public to the incumbent's foreign policies accomplishes nothing productive. Some have raised questions about Ford's views being embargoed until after his death. This is not an unusual practice at all. Indeed, Harry Truman wrote entire books that were not published until fifteen years after his death (Where The Buck Stops. Another book of secret interviews that was almost poisonous in its tone toward Eisenhower, Merle Miller's Plain Speaking was released shortly after Truman's death,) and those were harshly critical of his successors. What is unusual is that the tapes were released within 24 hours of Ford's death. But that is a decision that Bob Woodward and The Washington Post made, not President Ford. I suspect that he would never have agreed to have those quotes made public at this time. It is important to remember that the interviews took place in the context of a "future book" that Woodward planned on writing. That being the case, it is reasonable to conclude that Ford believed that those quotes would not be disclosed for several years, when either Iraq stabilized or American forces had withdrawn. I don't think any reasonable person believes that Gerald Ford would sabotage George Bush's war from beyond the grave, particularly when Mr. Bush has done more than enough to sabotage it from 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue. If anyone should be damned for putting the quotes out there now, it is Bob Woodward, not Gerald Ford. But that is difficult to do, given the close relationship that the president and his senior staff had with Woodward during the writing of his first two books on the Bush administration. Ford's characterizations of Dick Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld and Henry Kissinger are entertaining, but not particularly newsworthy. Of some historical interest is the fact that Rumsfeld knew nothing about the "Halloween massacre," where Kissinger was removed as National Security Advisor, and Secretary of Defense James Schlesinger was fired and replaced with Rumsfeld. It was wiely assumed that the move was engineered by chief of staff Rumsfeld and his deputy, Cheney. The shake-up was believed to be a masterstroke of political manoeuvring by Rumsfeld. Instead, he resented it deeply. That same year, Ford also decided to fire Defense Secretary James R. Schlesinger and replace him with Rumsfeld, who was then Ford's White House chief of staff. Ford recalled that he then used that decision to go to Kissinger and say, "I'm making a change at the secretary of defense, and I expect you to be a team player and work with me on this" by giving up the post of security adviser. Kissinger was not happy. "Mr. President, the press will misunderstand this," Ford recalled Kissinger telling him. "They'll write that I'm being demoted by taking away half of my job." But Ford made the changes, elevating the deputy national security adviser, Brent Scowcroft, to take Kissinger's White House post.
Throughout this maneuvering, Ford said, he kept his White House chief of staff in the dark. "I didn't consult with Rumsfeld. And knowing Don, he probably resented the fact that I didn't get his advice, which I didn't," Ford said. "I made the decision on my own."
The portrait painted of Kissinger is hardly new. Tales of his constant resignation threats have been detailed in literally dozens of books. It wasn't widely known that they continued after the fall of 1973, when his main competitors for influence with the president, H.R Haldeman, John Ehrlichman and Secretary of State William Rogers left the Nixon administration, but they are hardly surprising. By then Watergate had almost totally consumed Nixon's presidency and Kissinger was the last asset the president had. It should surprise no one that Kissinger would resume his prior behaviour when his influence was diminished in the new administration.
Indeed, one could argue that Kissinger's tantrums were the causus beli of what became Watergate. Accounts of the secret Cambodian bombing campaign had appeared in the press after the Nixon administration had denied it publicly. Consequently, Kissinger and Nixon had J. Edgar Hoover wiretap the home telephones of four journalists and eleven members of Kissinger's National Security Council staff in an effort to determine who the leaker was. Those wiretaps were revealed in the summer of 1974, and caused Kissinger to threaten to resign during a press conference in Austria.The "Plumber's Unit" that was discovered in the Watergate Hotel was actually the direct result of another Kissinger tirade. When Daniel Ellsberg released the Pentagon Papers (a classified study of the Vietnam War's escalation ordered by President Johnson's Secretary of Defense, Robert McNamara) to The New York Times and The Washington Post, Nixon was originally pleased. This was because the study was conducted before he took office and therefore embarrassed the Johnson and Kennedy administrations. Kissinger on the other hand was furious. He told Nixon that the leak could destroy the then-secret "China opening." Nixon's views on the release of the papers changed very quickly. Since the FBI had lost the confidence of the president at that point, Nixon ordered the creation of a secret White House "plumbers unit," to investigate and intimidate Ellsberg. Among the operations it conducted was a break-in of his psychiatrist's office in Los Angeles. How the plumbers ended up in a purely political operation, like the Watergate break-in remains unknown to this day. All told, the tapes are fascinating. While I regret, as President Ford would, that they came out now, they are out there. Hopefully more comes of them soon. It would be tragic if Woodward didn't produce the book that he told Ford he was writing and those tapes became another sensationalistic "scoop of the day" for The Washington Post.
Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: No More Mr. Nice Guy By: Alice Cooper From: Alice Cooper's Greatest HitsPermalink Labels: Fun With Politics, Journalists Are Swine, The Serious Side of skippy
|
|
|
Wednesday, December 27, 2006
|
|
"THE PRESIDENT OF ALL THE PEOPLE" A EULOGY FOR GERALD R. FORD
I am acutely aware that you have not elected me as your President by your ballots, and so I ask you to confirm me as your President with your prayers. And I hope that such prayers will also be the first of many. If you have not chosen me by secret ballot, neither have I gained office by any secret promises. I have not campaigned either for the Presidency or the Vice Presidency. I have not subscribed to any partisan platform. I am indebted to no man, and only to one woman--my dear wife--as I begin this very difficult job.
have not sought this enormous responsibility, but I will not shirk it. Those who nominated and confirmed me as Vice President were my friends and are my friends.
They were of both parties, elected by all the people and acting under the Constitution in their name. It is only fitting then that I should pledge to them and to you that I will be the President of all the people. -President Gerald Ford, August 9, 1974
Gerald R. Ford, the 38th president of the United States and perhaps the most fundamentally decent man to hold that office, died late last night. He was 93 years old and the longest living of the 42 presidents.
During all of the ceremony following President Reagan's death two and half years ago, I wondered what would happen when President Ford died and how he would be remembered. I've continued to think about that from time to time. I can only hope that history is kinder to him than his contemporaries were.
It is said that Mr. Ford never had an unkind word to say about anyone, in public or in private. Despite this, he was ridiculed while in office and generally forgotten after he left the national stage in 1977. President Ford, along with the first President Bush, is one of the very few national leaders in my lifetime that I had a genuine personal affection for. He was a good and noble man who entered office in the most difficult circumstances in his country's history, and he was never really given a fair shot.
Living as I do under a parliamentary system of government, I do not find unelected leaders all that unusual. Ford however was the only such president in American history - nominated and confirmed by Congress to replace Vice-President Spiro Agnew and elevated to the presidency upon Richard Nixon's resignation. Nixon's selection of Ford as vice-president was one of the last great decisions of his administration. There wasn't a better man to succeed him and heal the nation.
Anyone who thinks Washington is mired in a poisonous political atmosphere today should really study the period from 1966-76. The twin calamities of Vietnam and Watergate led to the single most dangerous period since the Civil War. Failed presidencies were becoming the rule, rather than the exception to it. Lyndon Johnson and Richard Nixon - two great, if deeply flawed men - had been hounded out of out of office. In his retirement, Johnson remembered hearing what he called "that awful song;" "Hey, Hey, LBJ / How many kids did you kill today." During Watergate, the White House was often surrounded by signs that read "Jail to the Chief." And by 1974, that had become an accepted part of civic discourse.
Because of the deep trauma of the Vietnam War, America began to doubt its place in the world at a time when American meekness could have led to nuclear annihilation. Because of Watergate, the very foundations of the Executive Branch and the national security state were called into question and the United States could have reverted to an earlier era of congressional government reminiscent of the one following the Civil War between 1865 and 1901. Kennedy had been assassinated, Johnson was hounded from office, Nixon was forced to resign, and Ford and Carter were both beaten after one term. That seventeen year period of failed presidencies, combined with Congressional hearings into virtually everything the executive branch had done during that period, threatened the separation of powers outlined in the Constitution. Had a lesser man succeeded Nixon, the presidency itself could have been crippled.
Being one of the very few presidents to move directly from the legislative branch to the executive, it may have been thought that Ford would have deferred to congressional prerogatives. Instead, he was one of the most forceful advocates of his office in recent memory. In his 29 months as president, he vetoed 66 bills. The current president has vetoed one in six years. Despite not having been elected president, Ford did not shirk one of the most controversial and difficult decisions of the last forty years, the pardon of Richard Nixon.
By the time of Nixon's resignation, Watergate had being tearing America apart for twenty-five months. For the first time, a president of the United States had been forced to resign. The United States was more divided than at any time since Reconstruction.
If Nixon were indicted, even the special prosecutor conceded that it might take as long as two years for him to receive a fair trial by an impartial jury. Such a trial might have taken as long as a year. Any conviction would certainly been followed by years of appeals, after which a future president might well have pardoned Nixon anyway. Watergate could very well have stretched into the Eighties and the political divisions would have continued and deepened.
Gerald Ford knew that pardoning Nixon could very well cost him his presidency. When confronted with a decision that was bad for him politically, but good for his country, he chose his country. It was one of the most courageous and even heroic decisions a president has made in my lifetime. All of the goodwill that he came into office with evaporated and his administration ended before it really began. But almost everyone now agrees that it was the right thing to do and he never wavered from that belief.
As David Gergen pointed out in his book, Eyewitness to Power, Ford had the most capable White House staff of the post-World War II era. Among those Gergen served with were George H.W Bush, Henry Kissinger, Alan Greenspan, Brent Scowcroft, James Baker, Donald Rumsfeld and Dick Cheney.
Besides being the healer of a nation, President Ford was perhaps the last Republican who was conservative in the way I consider myself conservative. He believed that government had no role in the private lives of the citizenry. He did not engage in spending sprees while cutting taxes. He wouldn’t have invaded countries without first having realistic goals as to how to administer them and extricate American forces. If he believed a bill was unconstitutional or bad for the country, he vetoed it. He believed in the separation of powers and the rule of law. He was a man of firm convictions, but was also aware that the world is a complicated place and nuance is important. In modern Republican circles, he is considered a liberal for these things.
Gerald Ford, rather than Jimmy Carter, might have been the ideal ex-president. He left Washington, wrote his memoirs, rarely spoke out on matters of public policy and never undermined his successors in the White House. He assisted his successors when asked and kept his feelings to himself when he wasn't. Ford understood, as Carter seemingly can't, that there can only be one president at a time.
I'd like to close with a statement President Ford made as he assumed office on August 9, 1974;
I believe that truth is the glue that holds government together, not only our Government but civilization itself. That bond, though strained, is unbroken at home and abroad.
In all my public and private acts as your President, I expect to follow my instincts of openness and candor with full confidence that honesty is always the best policy in the end.
My fellow Americans, our long national nightmare is over.
President Gerald R. Ford was the right man at the right time. America is a better place because he was its president and poorer place for his passing.
Godspeed, Mr. President.
Labels: The Serious Side of skippy
|
|
|
| |