Photobucket Enjoy Every Sandwich



Saturday, October 13, 2007


WHO KNEW? GENERAL RICARDO SANCHEZ AND THE CATASTROPHY IN IRAQ

As you probably know, the former commanding general of Operation Iraqi Freedom, Ricardo Sanchez yesterday came out against the war. And to think it only took him three years after leaving the theatre to do so.

The former top commander of U.S. troops in Iraq slammed the handling of the war and gave a bleak assessment of the current situation in Iraq.

"There is no question that America is living a nightmare with no end in sight," retired Lt. Gen. Ricardo Sanchez told a convention of military journalists on Friday.

Sanchez commanded U.S. troops in Iraq from June 2003 to July 2004. His controversial tenure saw the capture of Saddam Hussein and the handover of sovereignty to the Iraqi government, but also the rise of the insurgency and the Abu Ghraib prison scandal.

(...)

But Sanchez reserved most of his venom Friday for U.S. officials, saying the U.S. government still has not brought all the resources needed to win in Iraq.

"From a catastrophically flawed, unrealistically optimistic war plan, to the administration's latest surge strategy, this administration has failed to employ and synchronize the political, economic and military power," Sanchez said.

Continuing changes to military strategy alone will not achieve victory, rather it will only "stave off defeat," he said.

"The administration, Congress and the entire inter-agency, especially the State Department, must shoulder the responsibility for this catastrophic failure and the American people must hold them accountable."
No shit, Rick? Really? And here I was thinking that things were going so well.

Firstly, let me re-affirm that I supported the war, lest you think me some manner of lefty fuckhead. I've written more than enough about that support and the reasons behind it that I needn't restate my position here.

Having said that, the stated reasons for the war were incredibly stupid and the administration's projections were almost criminally optimistic. No one should ever tell people that their soldiers are going to "be greeted as liberators" as they are being sent into battle because most people - and Americans especially - are dumb enough to believe them. Not only were predictions criminally misleading, they were politically suicidal.

In the summer of 2002, I privately told a couple of friends in California that I wouldn't be at all surprised that the United States would suffer something in the neighbourhood of 10,000 casualties in the battle to eject Saddam alone. While the Iraqi army and, more importantly, the Republican Guard didn't put up much of a fight to hold Kuwait in 1991, defending their own homeland was very different. I, and more importantly, the military planners, envisioned a months-long siege of Baghdad that looked more like Stalingrad that what actually occurred.

Furthermore, if you really believed that the Ba'ath regime had WMD, it follows that they would use it to ensure its survival or to make the cost of destroying it unacceptably high. After all, Iraq used chemical weapons in its war against Iran and that didn't involve its own homeland defence.

Obviously, I was wrong, but I shouldn't have been, and the Bush administration should have told the American people to expect something along the line of my predictions. Firstly, they were entirely possibly and any student of history knows that. Secondly, even if proven wrong, such a casualty projection would let people see the current numbers, 4,500 dead, for what they are, incredibly low in a historical context.

No responsible leader should ever say that they are going to invade a country that is roughly equal to Texas in terms of size, geography and population without anyone getting hurt. One of the great lessons of Vietnam is that if the country isn't prepared for the inevitable casualties, domestic support for the war quickly evaporates. And that's pretty much what happened in Iraq. Cheney never tired of saying that American forces would be greeted with candy and blowjobs, and when the insurgency started, support for the entire exercise melted away.

The most important factor in any military conflict is the domestic will to win. Once that's gone, you're finished. Christ, even a monster like William Randolph Hearst understood that if you're going to manufacture a war, you had damn well get the public on board and keep them there.

Sanchez is generally right in his criticism, but wrong in the specifics. It wasn't Congress or the Department of State that set the troop levels for the invasion which ultimately led us to where we are today. That was done by the civilians at the Department of Defense and specifically approved by the President of the United States.

This president's father determined that nearly 600,000 troops were necessary for the relatively simple task of ejecting Iraq from Kuwait, yet Donald Rumsfeld and George W. Bush figured that they could pull off the infinitely more difficult job of invading, occupying and pacifying a much larger country with less than a third of that force level. And no one - not the president, the generals, Congress, or the media ever question the wisdom of that in public. Everyone in official Washington thought that invading a huge country with fourteen Americans, eight Englishmen and a Pollack was a good idea.

Asked why he did not speak out about his concerns, Sanchez said general officers take an oath to carry out the orders of the president while in uniform.

“The last thing that America wants, the last thing that you want, is for currently serving general officers to stand up against our political leadership,” he said.

However, general officers do have the option of stepping down if they disagree with the country's leaders.

Sanchez said he felt he could not resign and go public with his reservations while he was in Iraq, because he feared that move could further jeopardize troops serving there.

“I think once you are retired, you have a responsibility to the nation, to your oath, to the country, to state your opinion,” he said.
Horseshit.

If there's one thing that I'm getting good and goddamn tired of, it's these generals who only speak out when they are safely retired and on the payroll of a super-enormous defence contractor. By staying silent while in uniform, these generals are guilty of a dereliction of duty.

And it should be remembered that General Sanchez was in command from June 2003 to July 2004. This is when things went from merely bad to irretrivably lost. I'm confident that the doomsday rubicon was crossed when Sanchez himself was in charge.

Sanchez's thoughts on his responsibilities as a retiree are nothing short of absolute nonsense and they suggest that he had no responsibilities as an active-duty flag officer. And that is wrong. The first responsibility of any officer is the protection of the men who serve under him to the maximum extent possible. Officers have the responsibility to not send their men into a suicide mission unless doing so is absolutely necessary to the success of the overall mission.

And the way that Rumsfeld and Bush constituted the invasion made the mission itself a suicidal. There was no way that the pacification of a hostile population that large could occur with a force that small in theatre and the senior uniform command knew it. They history on that is pretty clear at this point.

Knowing this, if a general has a "responsibility to the nation," it is to immediately resign and tell the country why. At a minimum, they have a legal obligation to testify truthfully to Congress about their reservations. Of the generals who have come out against the war since the 2003 invasion, a grand total of none have done so while still in uniform. Only one, General Eric Shinseki, fulfilled his obligations to Congress and the American people.

For Sanchez and his ilk to say that his resignation would "further jeopardize troops serving there" makes him either a liar or an idiot. How does his current critique jeopardize the troops any less now than it would have then? He would have been equally retired.

Sanchez makes the equally silly assertion that "general officers take an oath to carry out the orders of the president while in uniform."

Not so. If an officer receives an order that is either illegal or unduly dangerous to his men, he has the legal and moral obligation to disregard it and resign his commission. "Just following orders" hasn't been a defence - legal or otherwise - since the 1940s.

General officers achieve their rank because of their leadership qualities. To follow a political/military strategy that one knows to be dangerously flawed is the antithesis of leadership. It is nothing less than careerism of the lowest order. And for generals like Sanchez to continue to collect their pensions as they criticize a policy they themselves executed is an act of moral cowardice.

I hate what this war has become with all of my heart, but I refuse to take common cause with assholes like Ricardo Sanchez in doing so. This is a matter of principle for me, and dare I say, it's more principle than Sanchez himself ever demonstrated.

If there's anything worse than Monday morning quaterbacking from the guy who was actually throwing the ball on Sunday afternoon, I can't see it.

Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: Masters of War By: Bob Dylan From: The Freewheeling Bob Dylan

Permalink

Labels: , , ,

1:21 PM