Photobucket Enjoy Every Sandwich



Saturday, October 06, 2007


WORDS AND CONSEQUENCES

I supported the war in Iraq that removed Saddam Hussein from power. My reasons for doing so were completely different from those who waged that war and most of its other supporters.

I thought that the WMD argument that the Bush administration presented as a justification was nonsense, and I said so at the time. Using common sense, I assumed that there would only be a first use or transfer to terrorists of WMD by Iraq if the Ba'ath regime were mortally threatened. After all, one doesn't usually engage in an act of suicide unless one is already facing certain death.

Nor was I particularly persuaded by the atrocities that Saddam had committed - and continued to commit - against his own people. If one were to trouble themselves with listing the countries and regimes on earth by their brutality against their citizenry, Iraq would have a very difficult time breaking into the top five.

Domestic barbarism is not now a driving force behind American foreign policy and it never was. Germany's actions toward the Jews began long before the United States entered World War II and President Roosevelt never spoke publicly about them once it had. The United States did not intervene to stop the genocide in Rwanda and, unlike former President Clinton, I don't think it should have.

I supported the war for the simple reason that Saddam Hussein could not be trusted to keep the regional peace. He launched two unprovoked invasions of his neighbours; Iran in 1979, and Kuwait in 1990. Iraq was contained, for a time, by the United Nations Security Council, but the sanctions that were in place were easily evaded by Iraq and the support for them in the U.N was rapidly eroding.

If the sanctions fell apart, history indicates that Iraq would have gone on an arms-buying binge and attacked another of its neighbours sooner or later. As in 1991, that would have required American intervention. If the question was taking down the regime when it was weak, or waiting until it was strong, I preferred the former.

I also knew what the likely consequences would be in the summer of 2002. I was aware of the possibilty that the country could disintegrate into sectarian violence that could potentially envelop the region.

However, I thought that the Bush national security apparatus was experienced and wise enough to see these things as well, and would strive to prevent those outcomes as much as was possible. It is important to remember that while President Bush was a novice Texas governor, Dick Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld, Colin Powell, Condolezza Rice and Paul Wolfowitz had well over a century of foreign policy experience between them.

I supported them to conduct an operation that I wouldn't have trusted with, say, the Clinton administration. Needless to say, I was wrong.

The Bush administration relied more on idealism than on wisdom. There was almost no forward planning and the inserted force was woefully inadequate. The invasion was designed almost solely to prove or disprove a light force projection theory of Rumsfeld's.

The Coalition Provisional Authority was staffed by hacks and political contributors to the president's first election campign and the Republican National Committee. So ideological were they that Iraqis were given a flat tax before it could guarantee electricity or reliable water service. The decisions to disband the military and de-Ba'athify the civil service took a relatively small insurgency and made it massive, threatening and unstoppable.

Not only should President Bush's Iraq adventure be compared to Vietnam, it should be unfavorably compared. Vietnam was escalated in secret after President Johnson knew that the cause was lost. President Bush refused to escalate when it could have actually accomplished something in mid-2003 and has the temerity to question the sense of anyone who opposes his current, all-too-late escalation.

I believe all of the above to be grounds for impeachment. If federal judges who were confirmed by the Senate can be removed from office for drunkeness and insanity, a president can so be convicted for misdministration of office. If any of you operated your cars the way this president has conducted foreign policy, you would be convicted of criminal negligence and/or vehicular homicide.

The way that George Bush, Dick Cheney and Donald Rumsfeld invaded Iraq created a civil war. If American forces are withdrawn any time in the next five years, they could possibly create a holocaust. If that isn't an impeachable offense, I'm not sure what actually is.

In any event, for the United States to leave the Iraqis to persue a genocide they made possible would constitue a crime against humanity. All pretending to the contrary aside, the United States is the government of Iraq and will be for some time.

Christopher Hitchens supported the war for purely moral reasons. He was of a mind that Saddam was an evil fellow and long-overdue for removal. While not a wholehearted Bushie, Hitchens stayed on the Iraq bandwagon far longer than did most sensible people.

I disagree with Mr. Hitchens in some areas and agree with him heartily in others. However, he is a truly brilliant writer and rarely diappoints, regardless of your perspective. His articles and, in particular, his interviews, never fail to entertain and educate. As much as there can be a Mencken for our time now that Hunter Thompson is gone, Christopher Hitchens is it.

Unlike most bloggers, Hitchens has a much higher platform and a far greater voice. That voice has consequences that I'm sure that he never imagined.

In the upcoming issue of Vanity Fair, Mr. Hitchens comes face to face with that responsibilty. He learned that his writings directly influenced 23 year old Mark Jennings Daily, born on the Fourth of July, to enlist to fight in Iraq, where Lieutenant Daily was killed by an IED in Mosul on January 15, 2007.

I can't imagine what it would be like for something I've written to have such enormous human consequences, and I don't think Mr. Hitchens ever did either.

Hitchens did something that must have been agonizing for him, he contacted Lieutenant Daily's family, and participated in the interment of their son / brother / husband's ashes. In his account of the aftermath of Mark's death, we learn something far more important than the truism that the boys and girls who wear the uniform are heroes, more often than not, their families are, too. The soldiers are gone, but we should always keep in mind the families of the fallen.

I'm not going to blockquote the Hitchen's article at length, because you should read it for yourselves. But there is one part of it that the casual reader of my stupid blod should see. That's from the last letter Lieutenant Daily sent to his wife, Snejana.

One thing I have learned about myself since I've been out here is that everything I professed to you about what I want for the world and what I am willing to do to achieve it was true. …

My desire to "save the world" is really just an extension of trying to make a world fit for you.


Can you imagine the depth of the love behind that sentiment? Think of what Lieutenant Daily could have achieved as a husband, as a father and a teacher.

That's what we lost this past January.

I hope that everyone who visits this stupid blog, clicks through and reads Christopher Hitchens' article. Better yet, I hope they buy the magazine itself.

And regardless of your feelings about the war, keep the memories of the fallen and your prayers for their families in your hearts.

Link Ruthlessly Stolen From The Ace of Spades HQ

Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: Soldier's Things By: Tom Waits From: Swordfishtrombones

Peramalink

Labels: ,

2:03 PM