|
|
Tuesday, December 11, 2007
|
|
SHOULD THIS MAN GO TO PRISON? JOHN KIRIAKOU & THE MEANING OF TORTURE
Today, on the United Nations International Day in Support of Victims of Torture, the United States declares its strong solidarity with torture victims across the world. Torture anywhere is an affront to human dignity everywhere. We are committed to building a world where human rights are respected and protected by the rule of law.
Freedom from torture is an inalienable human right. The Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment, ratified by the United States and more than 130 other countries since 1984, forbids governments from deliberately inflicting severe physical or mental pain or suffering on those within their custody or control. Yet torture continues to be practiced around the world by rogue regimes whose cruel methods match their determination to crush the human spirit. Beating, burning, rape, and electric shock are some of the grisly tools such regimes use to terrorize their own citizens. These despicable crimes cannot be tolerated by a world committed to justice.
(...)
The United States is committed to the world-wide elimination of torture and we are leading this fight by example. I call on all governments to join with the United States and the community of law-abiding nations in prohibiting, investigating, and prosecuting all acts of torture and in undertaking to prevent other cruel and unusual punishment. I call on all nations to speak out against torture in all its forms and to make ending torture an essential part of their diplomacy. I further urge governments to join America and others in supporting torture victims' treatment centers, contributing to the UN Fund for the Victims of Torture, and supporting the efforts of non-governmental organizations to end torture and assist its victims.
No people, no matter where they reside, should have to live in fear of their own government. Nowhere should the midnight knock foreshadow a nightmare of state-commissioned crime. The suffering of torture victims must end, and the United States calls on all governments to assume this great mission.
-President George W. Bush June 26, 2003 I'm highly conflicted about the issue of torturing terrorism suspects. On one hand, I hope that those people are uncomfortable in the extreme. On the other, I don't like what it does to the United States of America, which as a general rule, is better than the people it goes to war with.
When people like Colin Powell and John McCain say that torture is unacceptable, I'm inclined to listen. McCain has a pretty intimate familiarity with torture, having suffered five and a half years of it in the Hanoi Hilton. I'd say that makes him a much better authority on the issue than President Bush or Vice-President Cheney.
Of course, the Bush Administration changed the definition of tortue in such a way that almost nothing qualifies. Under the new definition, on those activities that "result in major organ failure or death" can be considered torture.
That leads to some pretty important questions. Is it then acceptable to cut off the hands of a detainee? How about raping the wife or daughter of one before his eyes? Under the Bush definition, neither qualifies as torture. They are, however, means by which the Ba'athist government of Saddam Hussein conducted business. By all acounts, it was highly effective.
That raises an important question: does the United States want to be on the same moral plane as Saddam Hussein?
The argument for waterboarding and other "enhanced techniques" is that certain detainees have information that is so important that extraordinary measures are justified in getting it. Lives can and have been saved, you will be told.
If that is the case - and I have no doubt that it is - then why not remove a hand or assault the terrorist's family?
And therein lies my problem with enhanced interrogation techniques, the slippery slope that it puts us on. You can justify almost anything, but you quickly become exactly what you're fighting.
Under international law, terrorists are unlawful combatants and may be executed without trial upon their capture. I have no quarrel with that whatsover. If it were up to me, it would happen a lot more than it actually does. I couldn't be more supportive of assassination, which is also perfectly legal under both U.S and international law. Under Executive Orders 11905 and 12333 only political assassinations - meaning killing a head of state or government official - is prohibited. Not only is Osama bin Laden not a government official, he has been officially stateless since his Saudi citizenship was revoked in 1994. No one in al-Qaeda is covered under the 1976 and '81 executive orders.
That's fine. This is, after all, a war on terror. Combatants have been executed on the battlefield for as long as war has existed.
Before today, we had never heard from an American official who readily admits to having engaged in torture. John Kiriakou, a former CIA officer, spoke with ABC News about what he did.
In watching the video of the interview, which I encourage you all to do, you cannot help but like Mr. Kirakou. You also can't help but feel a great deal of distaste over what he did in the service of the CIA. He certainly seems to and states his opinion that the practice of waterboarding should be discontinued.
I'm inclined to agree. Despite whatever executive orders have been issued and whatever opinions the Department of Justice has issued, waterboarding and enhanced interogation techniques are of questionable legality under American law and are clearly unacceptable under international law. The FBI is specifically prohibited from participating in such interrogations for good reason.
Even if circumstances warrant something like waterboarding, that does not mean that the practice should be enshrined in American law. Firstly, it can't be, as the United States is a signatory to several treaties regarding torture and those treaties have the full force and effect of federal law. Since they were ratified by the senate, a president can't over-rule them with an executive order or an intelligence finding. Secondly, it isn't a practice that anyone would want to see become commonplace, which it almost certainly would if Congress allowed for it. Remember how the USA Patriot Act was only supposed to be used in the War on Terror? Well, now it's a tool in the drug war and even some tax evasion cases.
If a CIA officer engages in waterboarding or something like it, he or she should do so knowing that they are exposing themselves to possibile prosecution. If it turns out that there really was no other reasonable alternative, that officer may receive congressional immunity or a presidential pardon. But if an alternative to enhanced techniques exists, those techniques should be used instead of something like waterboarding.
It isn't waterboarding itself that I object to, it's where the practice can potentially lead. If simulated drowning is acceptable, why not electrocution? Why not burn the hands and feet of a captured terrorist? In controlled cases, neither of those would lead to organ failure or death.
But once retired CIA officers who have participated in waterboarding say that it shouldn't be used, we should listen.
Link ruthlessly stolen from Captain's Quarters
Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: Drown in My Own Tears By: Ray Charles From: The Birth of Soul
PermalinkLabels: I Fought The Law, The Serious Side of skippy
|
|
|
| |