Photobucket Enjoy Every Sandwich



Saturday, March 08, 2008


THE BUSH DOCTRINE IN THEORY AND PRACTICE: INCOMPETENCE, HYPOCRISY AND GAZA

Almost from the second he was sworn in as president, George W. Bush began building a foreign policy on a foundation of falsehoods, fantasy and delirium tremens. During the 2004 Democratic primaries, Dick Gephardt described the incumbent president as a "miserable failure," which was something of an understatement. The message however was lost in the fact that Dick Gephardt has no eyebrows.

Despite campaigning on the premise that nation building was something that the United States was best kept far away from, Bush soon decided that he couldn't be a truly failed president until he embraced democracy without ever considering it's implications. This is seemingly key. For that reason, the Iraqi people were relentlessly bombed into the freedom to persue their deepest desire, murdering one another.

To be fair, the president couldn't possibly have known the consequences of the sudden liberation of repressed and atagonistic ethnic groups. It's not like there was any precedent for that. If only there was an experience to draw upon, like in the Balkans, say, ten years before ...

Anyhow, getting people of different ethnic and religious backgrounds to annhiliate one another with car bombs gets tired after a while. That's when you graduate to getting competing terrorist groups to kill one another.

It's kind of a complicated process, so you'll need to bear with me.

First, you get a bunch of terrorists together, give them two slivers of shithole land and let them think it might actually be a country. It's also important that said assholes of land sandwich a country that everybody wants destroyed. Then you force an election that all but the craziest motherfuckers in the region don't want. Then you just add water and stir.

From the enshrinment of the Oslo accords through 2006, the Palestinian Authority was ruled by the Fatah faction of what was formerly known as the Palestinian Liberation Organization. Fatah, and the PLO before it, was little more than a personality cult built around its leader, Yasser Arafat, and defined by his almost physically overwhelming corruption. From time to time, Arafat would allow one of his factions, the al-Aqsa Martyrs' Brigades, to launch terrorist assaults into Isreal as a means of keeping his kleptocracy undisturbed. When Arafat finally had the common decency to die in November of 2004, things got complicated fast.

However, and this is important to remember, the government of Israel continued to deal with Fatah at some level if only because the alternatives were so much worse than Arafat was. Even when the Israeli Defense Force was launching offensives into Gaza and blockading Arafat in his own headquarters, they still recognized Fatah as the legitimate government of the Palestinian Authority.

The Bush administration went much further than did even Israel. They refused to meet with Arafat at all. President Bush and then-National Security Advisor Condolezza Rice, neither of whom even pretended to know very much about the Middle East, positioned themselves to the right of Prime Minister Ariel Sharon vis-a-vis the Palestinans.

Upon Arafat's death, the Fatah leadership was assumed by Mahmoud Abbas. Within a year, Ariel Sharon slipped into an irreversible coma and was succeeded by Ehud Olmert. Unfortunately, Bush and Rice stayed exactly where they were and and made destroying the region something of a hobby.

As we have seen in both Afghanistan and Iraq, President Bush has something of a democracy fetish. The problem is - as scholars of German history have noted - that when you inject democracy into chaos, Adolf Hitler tends to wind up in power. And the Middle East has a long and storied history of chaos.

Bush continued his nonsensical chorus for elections in the Palestinan Authority that began in January of 2001. What followed demonstrates that President Bush not only doesn't understand the Middle East, it also shows that he doesn't understand electoral politics very well.

Fatah was a cauldron of corruption that supported limited terrorism, yet was publicly defined by a personality cult. When the personality heading the cult left the scene, all that was left was the corruption and the conflicting measures in dealing with Israel.

On the other hand, there was never any doubt what Hamas stood for; unlimited terrorism and the ultimate destruction of the Jewish state. But Hamas was also socially active in ways that Fatah never was. They built schools and maintained sewer services, y'know, the kind of shit that you cast ballots for. Much of the infastructure that should have been built and maintained by Fatah was instead the creation of Hamas.

Whether the Palestinian people support terrorism is debatable and electorally insignificant. Hamas made the trains run on time and put the kids in school, which is something that Arafat and Abbas never could. Anyone who knows anything about politics could have told the president of the United States who would win an election between the two.

In fact, both Fatah and the Israelis told the administration what would come of an election in the PA. They knew that Hamas would not only win, but win in a landslide that would destroy the peace process, perhaps forever.

The upcoming issue of Vanity Fair tells the story of what happened next in almost excruciating detail. After reading it, the only people left defending the competence of the Bush foreign policy will be drunkards, the addled, the insane and the most evil people among us.


Dahlan says he warned his friends in the Bush administration that Fatah still wasn't ready for elections in January. Decades of self-preservationist rule by Arafat had turned the party into a symbol of corruption and inefficiency - a perception Hamas found it easy to exploit. Splits within Fatah weakened its position further: in many places, a single Hamas candidate ran against several from Fatah.

"Everyone was against the elections," Dahlan says. Everyone except Bush. "Bush decided, 'I need an election. I want elections in the Palestinian Authority.' Everyone is following him in the American administration, and everyone is nagging Abbas, telling him, 'The president wants elections.' Fine. For what purpose?"

The elections went forward as scheduled. On January 25, Hamas won 56 percent of the seats in the Legislative Council.

Few inside the U.S. administration had predicted the result, and there was no contingency plan to deal with it. "I've asked why nobody saw it coming," Condoleezza Rice told reporters. "I don't know anyone who wasn’t caught off guard by Hamas’s strong showing."
This begs the very important question of just who the Secretary of State is hanging out with?

For a time, the United States believed that Hamas could be brought into the "roadmap" process defined by the U.S, U.N, Russia and the European Union. That illustrates an almost stunning ignorance of not just foreign policy, but basic electoral politics. Expecting Hamas to abandon antogonism to Israel is like expecting the Republican Party to abandon poorly thought out tax cuts and bending over for people like Pat Robertson, which is to say it that isn't something that would happen after a smashing success at the polls. Imagine Lincoln recinding the Emancipation Proclomation in March of 1865 and you sort of get an idea of how well it would work.

What Bush and Rice did in the aftermath of the Palestinian elections not only undermined their own silly "freedom agenda," it set back the credibility of the United States in the region for decades.

Essentially, the administration sought to reverse the results of a free and fair election that nobody wanted but them. And they did so by actually giving military aid to the losers of the election. As you might imagine, overturning the popular will of the Palestinian people tends to undermine your committment to freedom somewhat. That's particularly true if that popular will would never have been expressed in the first place but for your insistence.

The problem was that the newly Democratic Congress refused to authorize lethal military aid for Fatah for fear that it would end up in the hands of Hamas and be used to threaten Israel. But, as Karl Rove teaches us, the Democrats are almost always with the terrorists, so they could be safely ignored.

Of course, the go-to guy in the subsequent scheme was Elliott Abrams. Observers of recent American history might remember Mr. Abrams as a guy who pled guilty to his role in the Iran - Contra affair and was pardoned by the current president's father. That he served the current administration on the National Security Council, which doesn't require Senate confirmation, demonstrates that even the craveness of the Republican Congress of the day had its limits.

What essentially happened afterward is that the United States solicited military aid and training for Fatah's security services from third-party Arab governments, which is sort of what should have gotten President Reagan impeached.


The scheme bore some resemblance to the Iran-contra scandal, in which members of Ronald Reagan’s administration sold arms to Iran, an enemy of the U.S. The money was used to fund the contra rebels in Nicaragua, in violation of a congressional ban. Some of the money for the contras, like that for Fatah, was furnished by Arab allies as a result of U.S. lobbying.

But there are also important differences - starting with the fact that Congress never passed a measure expressly prohibiting the supply of aid to Fatah and Dahlan. "It was close to the margins," says a former intelligence official with experience in covert programs. "But it probably wasn’t illegal."
There are other similarities to Iran-Contra in this scheme. The original Reagan scheme was run out of the National Security Council in the White House basement. The NSC had absolutely no experience in running covert operations on its own and it was a miracle that Iran-Contra survived for the two years that it did. The more recent Bush plan was directed by the State Department, which has even less operational experience in covert action and a widely known reputation for leaks.

And leaks are exactly what happened. The operation, and the American fingerprints on it, leaked to the Arab media and gave Hamas plenty of time to prepare for and crush it. The secret coup against Hamas by Fatah and the United States was no longer secret. Yet, the plans and arms transfers continued. A covert operation that was no longer covert continued as if it was.

The results were disasterous. Not only did Hamas launch a preemptive strike that not only defeated Fatah, they slaughtered its loyalists in the streets. It was a horrific thing to watch, especially if you happened to be an Israeli within striking distance of Hamas' new terrorist stronghold. The arms that the United States skirted the law to transfer to Fatah now belong to Hamas and directly threaten Israel.

The operation was so badly bungled that the Fatah-loyalist al-Aqsa Martyrs' Brigades refused to participate in the defence of Gaza.


Others who stayed out of the fight were extremists. "Fatah is a large movement, with many schools inside it," says Khalid Jaberi, a commander with Fatah's al-Aqsa Martyrs' Brigades, which continue to fire rockets into Israel from Gaza. "Dahlan's school is funded by the Americans and believes in negotiations with Israel as a strategic choice. Dahlan tried to control everything in Fatah, but there are cadres who could do a much better job. Dahlan treated us dictatorially. There was no overall Fatah decision to confront Hamas, and that's why our guns in al-Aqsa are the cleanest. They are not corrupted by the blood of our people.”

Jaberi pauses. He spent the night before our interview awake and in hiding, fearful of Israeli air strikes. "You know," he says, "since the takeover, we've been trying to enter the brains of Bush and Rice, to figure out their mentality. We can only conclude that having Hamas in control serves their overall strategy, because their policy was so crazy otherwise."
You know that a policy is fatally flawed in it's concepetion and execution when even your enemies think that a disaster is what you specifically intended.

As a result of the incredibly awkward stumbling of President Bush and Secretary Rice, not only is Gaza gone, so is the somewhat moderate Fatah. If President Abbas has any hope whatsoever of maintaing power, he is going to distance himself from the United States and Israel in a demonstrable way, thus making an acheivable peace agreement even more difficult than it was before.

Ironically, during the 2000 campaign, President Clinton's Camp David summit was one of the things that George W. Bush railed against the most. His entirely Palestinian policy during the first term comprised of not being a tool of Yasser Arafat. That policy turned Gaza into a dagger pointed at Israel's heart. And it certainly doesn't help Egypt, which trained and participated in arming the Fatah security forces either.

And it isn't like the Bush administration wasn't warned. There were true American patriots like Brent Scowcroft who sounded the warning bells all along.


The status quo, Scowcroft said, is not necessarily a good thing, but it might be better than what follows. "My kind of realism would look at what are the most likely consequences of pushing out a government. What will replace it?" What will replace autocratic but stable governments, neoconservative thinkers say, is whatever the people of the Middle East decide will replace them. Robert Kagan, of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, and a Kristol ally, has written critically of the Bush Administration’s incomplete adherence to its own anti-tyranny doctrine. Referring to President Hosni Mubarak of Egypt, Kagan wrote, "Perhaps there is concern that too much pressure on Mubarak might produce a victory by the Muslim Brotherhood, the most popular Egyptian opposition party, which has been outlawed by the government. That's a risk, of course, but if the Bush Administration isn't willing to let Islamists, even radical Islamists, win votes in a fair election, then Bush officials should stop talking so much about democracy and go back to supporting the old dictatorships."

Scowcroft believes that the Administration has already gone too far in Kagan's direction. "Let's suppose Mubarak disappears and we have an election," he said. "The good guys are not going to win that election. The bad guys are going to win that election. The bad guys are always better organized. Always. The most ruthless, the tough ones, are the ones who are going to rise to the top in a chaotic society. That’s my fear."

The Bush Administration does not, as a rule, concede that democratization in the Middle East could lead to a series of Islamist states. One day, I mentioned to Scowcroft an interview I had had with Paul Wolfowitz, when he was Donald Rumsfeld’s deputy. Wolfowitz was the leading neoconservative thinker in the senior ranks of the current Bush Administration. (He is now the president of the World Bank.) I asked him what he would think if previously autocratic Arab countries held free elections and then proceeded to vote Islamists into power. Wolfowitz answered, “Look, fifty per cent of the Arab world are women. Most of those women do not want to live in a theocratic state. The other fifty per cent are men. I know a lot of them. I don’t think they want to live in a theocratic state."

Scowcroft said of Wolfowitz, "He's got a utopia out there. We're going to transform the Middle East, and then there won't be war anymore. He can make them democratic. He is a tough-minded idealist, but where he is truly an idealist is that he brushes away questions, says, 'It won't happen,' whereas I would say, 'It's likely to happen and therefore you can't take the chance.’ Paul's idealism sweeps away doubts." Wolfowitz, for his part, said to me, "It's absurdly unrealistic, demonstrably unrealistic, to ignore how strong the desire for freedom is."

Maybe not so much.

How can you call Afghanistan a democracy when the elected government only controls approximately 30% of its terroritory? How can you say that the surge in Iraq is a success when you don't know what will happen when the surge draws down? How can any rational person look at the Palestinian Authority or Lebanon and say that democracy is working? How can any right thinking human being look at what George W. Bush has done to the world and not say "What in the fuck has happened to American foreign policy?"

How can anyone call themselves a conservative and support anything that this president has done? President Bush has not only reversed the trends of the end of the Cold War, he's rapidly sending the world back into the Dark Ages.

Don't think that the next president is going to fix this, either. Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton are promising to further antagonize the rest of the world by reopening settled trade and defence agreements and John McCain is going to be a captive of his own idiot right.

Unfortunately, reasonable people like Richard Nixon and Gerald Ford are dead and Henry Kissinger, James Baker, Brent Scowcroft and the first President Bush are too old to do the decades of work that it will take to undo the disaster this administration has wrought.

A few years ago, I compared George W. Bush unfavorably to Lyndon Johnson. In retrospect, I was far too charitable in my evaluation of the current president. President Johnson only destroyed Vietnam and did a decade's worth of damage to the American economy. Even that was mitigated by his heroic stands in civil rights and the establishment of Medicare. Everything President George Walker Bush has gotten close to has been ruined almost beyond repair. The man is either incompetent, malevolent, cursed or all three.

Anyone who has ever wondered what Mr. Magoo would be like as president can put down their hashpipes.

Comparing Bush to other American presidents is a fool's game. By almost any standard, the guy falls short of even a shitheel like Fidel Castro in the leadership sweepstakes. Both have detained people under questionable circumstances in Cuba, but Castro was at least able to raise his nation's literacy rate. Cuban hospitals might be cesspools, but so is Walter Reed.

I love the United States and the American people with all of my heart, but I despair over what it's become over the last twenty years. As voters become increasingly disengaged with the electoral process, idealogical "base turnout" has become the most effective way to win. That means what P.J O'Rourke once lovingly described as "Bullshit, Money and Television" carries the day. And that's how people like Bill Clinton and George W. Bush come to power. I've spent way too many years and too much money studying the American presidency to see it become a tool by which one can get more blowjobs and wage epic Oedipal battles. The last sixteen years should demonstrate better than anything else what "process politics" brings.

I'm not going to stand here and tell you that my country is any better politically. In a lot of ways, Canada is far worse. We build up leaders only to destroy them forever and we're much better at it than Americans are.

But we don't tout ourselves as the "leader of the free world." We don't have a nuclear arsenal, a giant army or a tendency to fuck about in the politics of other nations. All of those things carry with them a special responsibility.

I know that Americans get awfully pissy when foreigners like me point out the flaws in your electoral process, but the decisions you make when you aren't eating pork rinds and beating your wives during Super Bowl commercials are felt around the world. Like it or not, that gives the rest of us the right to an opinion. I don't remember all of you Republican assholes getting all that uppity when a ton of Iraqis were waving purple fingers and sitting next to Laura Bush at the State of the Union address. You don't get to play policeman of the world unless we can see your badge.

Besides which, when American foreign policy irredeemably fucks up a place like, say, Central America or Somolia, Canadian peacekeepers get to go in and try to fix it without things like money and guns.

Any halfway smart person will read the next issue of Vanity Fair and ask what's worse; a country that deliberately arms and empowers terrorists, or one that does so by accident.

Special thanks to Daimnation

Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: A Small Victory By: Faith No More From: Angel Dust



Permalink

Labels: , ,

10:48 AM