WHO IS ABU ZUBAYHAH?
A couple of days ago I wrote about the interview given to ABC News by former CIA officer John Kiriakou. Mr. Kiriankou was directly involved in the capture of al-Qaeda operative Abu Zubaydah and his subsequent interrogation. While Kiriankou is adamant in stating that he did not take part in Zubaydah's waterboarding, he does assert his knowlege that it indeed took place as has been previously reported.
It was the first time that a current or former official admitted that such treatment took place. Previously, the party line was not to discuss intelligence gathering measures.
In the comments of my first little essay, the good and great Joan suggested that Mr. Kiriakou might have had a political motive for renouncing waterboarding;
I am inclined to listen closely to an ex-CIA operative. But it does not follow that I should be inclined to believe he is politically pure in his confessions, whichever way he paints it. He is trained, after all, to play in the field of deception. That's always possible, I suppose. So, I read the transcript of Kiriankou's ABC intereview. Here's how he describe Abu Zubaydah;
BRIAN:So you felt that he was-- he was very current. He knew what was going on.
JOHN: Very current. On top of-- of the current threat information he-- he was so well tied into the al Qaeda leadership, and he was-- he was highly thought of in al Qaeda, and he was very, very good at logistics, that we knew that he knew everybody who was worth knowing in al Qaeda. He knew cell leaders. That view is in keeping with a certain president that we all know and love.
Following his 28 March 2002 capture by the CIA and Pakastani authorities, President Bush gave a speech wherein he described Zubaydah and his importance.
The other day we hauled in a guy named Abu Zubaydah. He's one of the top operatives plotting and planning death and destruction on the United States. He's not plotting and planning anymore. He's where he belongs. I was interested at this point. As I was writing the first post, I was finishing Lawrence Wright's The Looming Tower: Al-Qaeda and the Road to 9/11. That book is considered the definitive history of the jihadist movement, winning the Pulitzer Prize and everything.
The Looming Tower names some 15-year-old kid who saved bin Laden's life during the anti-Soviet jihad and devotes two entire pages to his story. This book is so detailed that you learn the names of bin Laden and Zawahiri's wives and kids. The book should have been called Everything You Need to Know About Murderous Jihadi Garbage But Were Afraid to Ask.
Oddly enough, one of al-Qaeda's "top operatives" and someone "so well tied-into the al-Qaeda leadership" as Abu Zubaydah wasn't mentioned in the book. Not once. And The Looming Tower was written several years after Zubaydah's capture. After I finished writing that night, I even checked the index. I'm very thorough and this makes me both deeply sexy and highly annoying.
My curiosity now peaked, I began reading The One Percent Doctrine: Deep Inside America's Pursuit of Its Enemies Since 9/11 by Ron Suskind. Suskind's book has a great deal indeed to say about Zubaydah.
Since Zubaydah was captured in his Faisalabad hideout, the CIA also captured his computer and all of its contents. Those were turned over to an FBI agent named Dan Coleman, who had been investigating al-Qaeda since 1994 and was one of the foremost experts on them within the United States government in the days and months after 9/11.
In going through the contents of Zubaydah's computer, Coleman found a diary that went back a decade. And the contents of that diary were shocking indeed.
Zubaydah was a logistics man, a fixer, mostly for a niggling array of personal items, like the guy you call who handles the company health plan, or benefits, or the people in human resources. There was almost nothing "operational" in his portfolio. That was handled by the management team. He wasn't one of them
As disappointing as what was in the diary, Coleman's trained eye noticed what wasn't. The CIA had long suspected that the ubiquitous Zubaydah was involved in the August, 1998, bombings of the U.S embassies in Africa. He looked for enteries in the summer of 1998 in Zubaydah's diary. Nothing ... nothing but nonsense. (pages 95-96) Zubaydah was further described as "a travel agent, the guy who booked your flights" and "He was expendable, you know, the greeter ... Joe Louis in the lobby of Caesar's Palace, shaking hands." (page 100)
Of course, George Tenent devotes considerable space in his memoir to arguing with this assessment of Abu Zubaydah. However, he too has motive to shade the truth. After all, as Director of Central Intelligence, he was the guy who personally authorized Zubaydah's torture. I'm speculating here, but Tenent might look like a putz if he admitted to the Iraq "slam dunk" quote and to ordering the waterboarding of the wrong guy. You can only expect a guy to make himself look so bad in his own goddamned book before it gets humiliating.
For that reason, I wouldn't count on Vice-President Cheney's memoir verifying the Suskind account. As it is, he's going to have spend three or four chapters talking about shooting Harry Whittington in the face.
Furthermore, the CIA recently announced that it has it made it their practice to make the videotapes of these enhanced interrogations disappear. One of those tapes starred none other than Zubaydah. That those tapes were of some interest to various trial court judges and that their destruction may constitute an obstruction of justice seems to have mattered not at all. Christ, even Harriet Miers told the CIA not to destroy them. But who listens to Miers? She was just the lawyer of the president of the United States at the time. It appears that the only time the Agency listened to the Office of White House Counsel was when Alberto Gonzalez told them that the Geneva Conventions were "quaint."
This might be the most compelling reason to stay away from techniques like waterboarding. It makes one do things that are even dumber, more criminal and more politically damaging than the original act. As Richard Nixon taught us, "it's the cover-up that gets you."
Ron Suskind might be wrong in suggesting that Abu Zubaydah was the nerd among the cool kids. But he might be right. Would you admit to effectively torturing somebody you didn't have to? What would you do to avoid something like that becoming public knowledge? And what opinion do you think that the public would have about your competence and honesty if it did.
I agree with Joan that somebody might be spinning waterboarding for political purposes. I just disagree with her on who that might be and why. After all, John Kiriakou's public statements on the utility of Abu Zubaydah line up with those of George W. Bush rather nicely, so I doubt that he's a closet Democrat hunting for this president's scalp.
On the other hand, I could be wrong. It's been known to happen from time to time. At the end of the day, I'm not all twisted steel and sex appeal. Just 93%. I checked. The point is that I'm as imperfect as everybody else. I just don't like to advertise it.
None of the above should be taken to mean that I think that Zubaydah is by any means innocent. I think that membership in or association with al-Qaeda alone should get you a bullet in the head. But the U.S government vowed that things like waterboarding would be used sparingly and only on the worst of the worst. And that might not have been the case.
In any case, this story reminds me of Friedrich Nietzsche's advice to whoever fights monsters.
Easy Listening Recommendation of the Day: For Whom the Bell Tolls By: Metallica From: Ride the Lightning
PermalinkLabels: I See Monsters, The Death of Democracy, The Serious Side of skippy
|